Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2007-01-07 Thread Rahul Thakur
+1 Rahul Carlos Sanchez wrote: On 1/8/07, Brett Porter <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: On 27/12/2006, at 8:50 AM, Brett Porter wrote: > 1) Establish a list of emeritus committers. ok, this has been taken care of. I've added myself a todo to document what we have in place. > 2) Remove inter-pro

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2007-01-07 Thread Carlos Sanchez
On 1/8/07, Brett Porter <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: On 27/12/2006, at 8:50 AM, Brett Porter wrote: > 1) Establish a list of emeritus committers. ok, this has been taken care of. I've added myself a todo to document what we have in place. > 2) Remove inter-project commit restrictions > > The fi

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2007-01-07 Thread Brett Porter
On 27/12/2006, at 8:50 AM, Brett Porter wrote: 1) Establish a list of emeritus committers. ok, this has been taken care of. I've added myself a todo to document what we have in place. 2) Remove inter-project commit restrictions The first does not depend on the second. But I think the se

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2007-01-04 Thread Dennis Lundberg
Brett Porter wrote: Sorry, just catching up on a couple of these now. Myself and Brett can flip SVN bits and generally one of us is around. And if you're a committer you've already got access to sandboxes. I'm not really talking about the relative difficulty of granting access. Yes, that's q

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2007-01-04 Thread Trygve Laugstøl
Brett Porter wrote: Sorry, just catching up on a couple of these now. Myself and Brett can flip SVN bits and generally one of us is around. And if you're a committer you've already got access to sandboxes. I'm not really talking about the relative difficulty of granting access. Yes, that's q

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2007-01-03 Thread Brett Porter
Heh :) On 04/01/2007, at 5:36 PM, Dion Gillard wrote: That list is woefully out of date. This one is way more telling: http://maven.apache.org/maven-1.x/developer-activity-report.html On 12/29/06, Arnaud HERITIER <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > I'm just curious, what problem does establish

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2007-01-03 Thread Dion Gillard
That list is woefully out of date. This one is way more telling: http://maven.apache.org/maven-1.x/developer-activity-report.html On 12/29/06, Arnaud HERITIER <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > I'm just curious, what problem does establishing a list of emeritus > committers solve? When you see

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2007-01-03 Thread Brett Porter
Sorry, just catching up on a couple of these now. Myself and Brett can flip SVN bits and generally one of us is around. And if you're a committer you've already got access to sandboxes. I'm not really talking about the relative difficulty of granting access. Yes, that's quick. Though a vo

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2006-12-28 Thread Ralph Goers
Jason van Zyl wrote: People get voted on to the PMC by other PMC members. Being a committer doesn't automatically get you on the PMC in these parts. I'm personally not for the free-for-all access to everything. I don't honestly understand why there is any distinction between a committer a

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2006-12-28 Thread Jason van Zyl
On 28 Dec 06, at 9:50 PM 28 Dec 06, Ralph Goers wrote: I'm a little curious. I'm a committer on a few projects and am on the Cocoon PMC. This is the first time I've every heard of a proposal for people to automatically lose their commit privileges. Although, I haven't found any rules an

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2006-12-28 Thread Brett Porter
On 29/12/2006, at 1:50 PM, Ralph Goers wrote: I'm a little curious. I'm a committer on a few projects and am on the Cocoon PMC. This is the first time I've every heard of a proposal for people to automatically lose their commit privileges. Although, I haven't found any rules anywhere th

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2006-12-28 Thread Ralph Goers
I'm a little curious. I'm a committer on a few projects and am on the Cocoon PMC. This is the first time I've every heard of a proposal for people to automatically lose their commit privileges. Although, I haven't found any rules anywhere that says you can't do it, it seems a bit odd to me.

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2006-12-28 Thread Arnaud HERITIER
I'm just curious, what problem does establishing a list of emeritus committers solve? When you see this page [1], how many committers are there for maven 1 ? Who is active ? Arnaud [1] http://maven.apache.org/maven-1.x/team-list.html

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2006-12-28 Thread Alan D. Cabrera
On Dec 26, 2006, at 1:50 PM, Brett Porter wrote: Hi, I'd like to propose two things: 1) Establish a list of emeritus committers. 2) Remove inter-project commit restrictions The first does not depend on the second. But I think the second does depend on the first. I would like to put each to

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2006-12-28 Thread Jason van Zyl
On 28 Dec 06, at 8:35 AM 28 Dec 06, Trygve Laugstøl wrote: Brett Porter wrote: Hi, I'd like to propose two things: 1) Establish a list of emeritus committers. 2) Remove inter-project commit restrictions The first does not depend on the second. But I think the second does depend on the first.

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2006-12-28 Thread Trygve Laugstøl
Brett Porter wrote: Hi, I'd like to propose two things: 1) Establish a list of emeritus committers. 2) Remove inter-project commit restrictions The first does not depend on the second. But I think the second does depend on the first. I would like to put each to a separate vote once all the p

Re: [proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2006-12-26 Thread Jason van Zyl
On 26 Dec 06, at 4:50 PM 26 Dec 06, Brett Porter wrote: Hi, I'd like to propose two things: 1) Establish a list of emeritus committers. 2) Remove inter-project commit restrictions The first does not depend on the second. But I think the second does depend on the first. I would like to put

[proposal] Emeritus committers & removing inter-project commit restrictions

2006-12-26 Thread Brett Porter
Hi, I'd like to propose two things: 1) Establish a list of emeritus committers. 2) Remove inter-project commit restrictions The first does not depend on the second. But I think the second does depend on the first. I would like to put each to a separate vote once all the pros and cons have b