Re: how do we handle old taglib definitions in the sandbox

2006-10-14 Thread Martin Marinschek
+1 for a clear cut. When you upgrade your app to a new version of MyFaces, you'll surely be happy to have some of the components you used upgraded to tomahawk from the sandbox. You'll be ok with going through the code-base and doing a string-search-replace for the affected component-instances.

RE: how do we handle old taglib definitions in the sandbox

2006-10-13 Thread Scheper, Erik-Berndt
Isn't that the risk of using components of the sandbox? IMHO, sandbox components should always be subject to change without notice. If they are promoted to 'production quality', then so much the better. Therefore, my personal preference would be to remove all references in the sandbox after the

Re: how do we handle old taglib definitions in the sandbox

2006-10-13 Thread Werner Punz
I agree with you here, I think pulling the defs the hard way is the only option otherwise we will get into an utter mess. Since we have not promoted too many components yet, I was not sure if pulling the sandbox defs was a viable option, given the userbase this code already has. Scheper,

Re: how do we handle old taglib definitions in the sandbox

2006-10-13 Thread Ernst Fastl
On one hand it is right that components of the sandbox are potential subjects for change, but would it really hurt to do a slower deprecation? Like Werner pointed out, some people are already using sandbox components in their production environments although this may never have been recommended

Re: how do we handle old taglib definitions in the sandbox

2006-10-13 Thread Werner Punz
Ernst Fastl schrieb: On one hand it is right that components of the sandbox are potential subjects for change, but would it really hurt to do a slower deprecation? Like Werner pointed out, some people are already using sandbox components in their production environments although this may never

Re: how do we handle old taglib definitions in the sandbox

2006-10-13 Thread Ernst Fastl
I agree ,If deprecation is not really possible ( for now I could also not think of a appropriate way to do so) then the clear cut has to be done sooner or later anyway. And as erik-berndt already pointed out, the migration for the users will be just a text-replace in their jsps or facelet-xhtml