Re: Discuss about creating partitioned topic in V1

2022-05-10 Thread Matteo Merli
It's already deprecated. No one is encouraged to use v1 API except for users for Pulsar 1.x that had topics created with the old namings. What I'm proposing, instead of trying to fix the inconsistencies in that API, is to disable v1 API by default and leave a configuration option to turn it on in

Re: Discuss about creating partitioned topic in V1

2022-05-09 Thread Rajan Dhabalia
> Having said that, V1 admin API was in effect considered as "soft deprecated" since Pulsar 2.0. All documentation has been focused on v2 APIs. There are Orgs which have large scale Pulsar clusters and use V1 apis. There is no way we can deprecate V1 api and it has to be maintained until we find

Re: Discuss about creating partitioned topic in V1

2022-05-09 Thread guo jiwei
Thanks. @Matteo I will track this. Regards Jiwei Guo (Tboy) On Tue, May 10, 2022 at 7:37 AM Matteo Merli wrote: > Why I agree that it "looks like a bug", "walks like a bug" and "talks > like a bug"... > this was actually a "feature" :) > > not a good one, or with a good reason to exist, but

Re: Discuss about creating partitioned topic in V1

2022-05-09 Thread Matteo Merli
Why I agree that it "looks like a bug", "walks like a bug" and "talks like a bug"... this was actually a "feature" :) not a good one, or with a good reason to exist, but something we've been trying not to break. I'm not going to dig into the "wrong" reasoning on why this was done in the first

Re: Discuss about creating partitioned topic in V1

2022-05-09 Thread Enrico Olivelli
+1 I agree totally. It is a bug Enrico Il Lun 9 Mag 2022, 20:59 Michael Marshall ha scritto: > Great find, Jiwei Guo. I agree that this should be classified as a bug > and that we should change the V1 implementation so that a topic can > only be created if its namespace already exists. > >

Re: Discuss about creating partitioned topic in V1

2022-05-09 Thread Michael Marshall
Great find, Jiwei Guo. I agree that this should be classified as a bug and that we should change the V1 implementation so that a topic can only be created if its namespace already exists. Thanks, Michael On Mon, May 9, 2022 at 7:13 AM guo jiwei wrote: > > Hi, community: >I found that in the