No problem. I just haven't had time to formulate a response yet :-)
Greg
On Nov 27, 2006, at 2:02 PM, Ted Husted wrote:
Sorry for the rant. I would have just sent the last two paragraphs,
but the phone rang, and I pressed the wrong button :(
On 11/27/06, Ted Husted <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Sorry for the rant. I would have just sent the last two paragraphs,
but the phone rang, and I pressed the wrong button :(
On 11/27/06, Ted Husted <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Here's the thing: If all these other projects depend on Tiles, then
why are they not contributing? If other people won't co
On 11/27/06, Greg Reddin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> To create community, a codebase needs to stand on its own or be part
> of a larger umbrella project, like the Commons or the ASF itself.
I agree. I don't see this move as building community. It's just a
stepping stone on the path to indepen
On Nov 25, 2006, at 9:32 AM, Ted Husted wrote:
Could we also document the alternative of moving the org.apache.tiles
packages *into* the struts2-plugin?
The proposal cites three problems:
1 Can't release
2 Not visible
3 Not permanent
As part of the Struts2 Plugin, problems 1 and 2 will be so
I know I'd like to see Tiles live on its own somewhere other than
here. Tiles has forever been associated with Struts, and while the
code is now independent of Struts, just being here makes it "part of
Struts" in many people's minds.
I'd be +1 for Tiles going TLP, and if that means first g
On 11/24/06, David H. DeWolf <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
For the sake of documentation, I'll go ahead and take some of these (and
Ted's) points regarding where to go upon graduation and post them to the
wiki.
Thanks everyone for your continued input. . .
Could we also document the alternative o
For the sake of documentation, I'll go ahead and take some of these (and
Ted's) points regarding where to go upon graduation and post them to the
wiki.
Thanks everyone for your continued input. . .
David
Niall Pemberton wrote:
If tiles can achieve the critical mass to become a TLP then IMO
I know I might miss the struts2 release, but I'm going to let this sit
at least another day or two since some people haven't had a ton of time
to chime in and because of the US holiday this week. . .
David
David H. DeWolf wrote:
Please find the Tiles2 graduation proposal draft below. I look
Antonio Petrelli wrote:
David H. DeWolf ha scritto:
Please find the Tiles2 graduation proposal draft below. I look
forward to your feedback . . .
For the record, +1 Myself :)
+1, but I think that also Wendy should be put as an active participant,
since she helped us with Maven, gave a lo
If tiles can achieve the critical mass to become a TLP then IMO that
would be the best solution - at this point it looks at least a couple
of devs short of that. In the meantime its question of "where can it
do its growing?". Commons makes less sense to me than staying here
since theres definetly
When we invented the Commons, it was not our intention to exclude "web
components". If we had even suggested such a thing, I doubt that the
Jakarta PMC would have approved our proposal. At the time, we took the
notion that ASF projects were suppose to be tied to HTTPD very
seriously. Of course, si
On 11/23/06, Ted Husted <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
I'd like to see the proposal discuss the alternatives to becoming a
Struts subproject. A good role for a proposal is to summarize various
threads. Becoming a subproject seems to be a foregone conclusion of
the proposal, with no discussion of the
I'd like to see the proposal discuss the alternatives to becoming a
Struts subproject. A good role for a proposal is to summarize various
threads. Becoming a subproject seems to be a foregone conclusion of
the proposal, with no discussion of the alternatives.
In previous threads, Jakarta was ment
There's also a tradition in the Incubator of "co-signing" releases.
If the podling PMC votes on a release, and ithen any three members of
the Incubator PMC can authorize the release. If Tiles were release
ready, and we had at least three people here who were going to support
it, I'm sure we can w
David H. DeWolf ha scritto:
Please find the Tiles2 graduation proposal draft below. I look
forward to your feedback . . .
+1, but I think that also Wendy should be put as an active participant,
since she helped us with Maven, gave a lot of useful suggestions and
made tests.
Ciao
Antonio
-
Don Brown ha scritto:
+0 with the caveat that its temporary nature is very clearly marked on
the Struts site. We just finished fighting off the impression we are
a generic umbrella project, and I'd like to not go through that again.
Wiki just edited, it is the last sentence in the page.
Ciao
On Nov 22, 2006, at 12:51 PM, David H. DeWolf wrote:
Please find the Tiles2 graduation proposal draft below. I look
forward to your feedback . . .
http://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/S2WIKI/Tiles2+Graduation
+Proposal
+1 with one clarification. I think the Community Involvement s
+0 with the caveat that its temporary nature is very clearly marked on
the Struts site. We just finished fighting off the impression we are a
generic umbrella project, and I'd like to not go through that again.
Don
David H. DeWolf wrote:
Please find the Tiles2 graduation proposal draft below.
Please find the Tiles2 graduation proposal draft below. I look forward
to your feedback . . .
http://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/S2WIKI/Tiles2+Graduation+Proposal
David
Martin Cooper wrote:
Just write up a brief proposal that we can discuss, maybe on the wiki, as
Wendy suggested. On
19 matches
Mail list logo