ot: Re: Comment on StrutsChain Wiki

2005-01-12 Thread Vic
Sean Schofield wrote: JSF is really a complete application framework. It does pretty much everything Struts does (more or less) so I think that would make it a competitor of Struts. Struts allways had competitors. Trubine, the one w/ a beaver logo (what was that?). Now I can name a half a doz

Re: Comment on StrutsChain Wiki

2005-01-12 Thread Sean Schofield
I would disagree that these other technologies do not compete directly with Struts. For now, Shale is a Struts 2.x effort but Craig has made it clear that he is prepared to break if off from Struts if the Struts committers won't consider moving in that direction. JSF is really a complete applicat

Re: Comment on StrutsChain Wiki

2005-01-12 Thread Vic
Yes Sean I kind of disagree with you too. I think it's great that Struts is diverse and I hope it gets more so. My excuse is that I am working on JDNC a lot. I plan to integrate w/ Struts chain ... after it's released, so I do benefit from Joe's efforts; I just can't help him. I think it takes ti

Re: Comment on StrutsChain Wiki

2005-01-12 Thread Joe Germuska
The problem is that instead of there being just one large group working on Struts, that same group is starting to splinter into working on Jericho, Shale, Struts 1.3, MyFaces, etc. I know this is something that we'd all like to avoid because none of these worthy projects gets enough attention. You

Re: Comment on StrutsChain Wiki

2005-01-12 Thread Sean Schofield
Joe, A comment on your lack of feedback. It occurs to me that this is one of the unfortunate byproducts of the Struts development effort starting to fracture. In addition to my day job, I'm currently working on commons-chain and myfaces (plus JSF in general). That's about all of the time I have

Re: Comment on StrutsChain Wiki

2005-01-12 Thread Joe Germuska
At 12:10 PM -0600 1/12/05, Michael Rasmussen wrote: Just curious, where is this specific wiki page? I couldn't find a link to it from the main wiki page. http://wiki.apache.org/struts/StrutsChain -- Joe Germuska [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://blog.germuska.com "Narrow minds are weapons

Re: Comment on StrutsChain Wiki

2005-01-12 Thread Michael Rasmussen
Just curious, where is this specific wiki page? I couldn't find a link to it from the main wiki page. Michael On Wed, 12 Jan 2005 09:44:54 -0600, Joe Germuska <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > At 10:35 AM -0500 1/12/05, Sean Schofield wrote: > >Joe, > > > >Sounds like you are moving right along with

Re: Comment on StrutsChain Wiki

2005-01-12 Thread Joe Germuska
At 10:35 AM -0500 1/12/05, Sean Schofield wrote: Joe, Sounds like you are moving right along with StrutsChain. I liked your idea of moving the properties from WebActionContext into the base ActionContext. I agree that those things would exist in any given Struts environment. Also it would probab

Comment on StrutsChain Wiki

2005-01-12 Thread Sean Schofield
Joe, Sounds like you are moving right along with StrutsChain. I liked your idea of moving the properties from WebActionContext into the base ActionContext. I agree that those things would exist in any given Struts environment. Also it would probably simplify things for the user (they don't have