Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-08 Thread Vitor Souza
> > Vitor Souza wrote: > > > However, if you'd like I could create a JIRA > (Bugzilla?) issue [...] > > > > > Yes, please create the ticket. Unfortunately, I > don't believe there is > > anyone left who _does_ have enough knowledge of > OGNL > > to truely vet it :( Here it goes: https://issue

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-06 Thread tm jee
> Well, since we have full access to OGNL, why can't we just make the > changes we need? Patrick should be able to hook us up :) Sounds cool. For those who are interested, more info about OGNL could be found at http://www.opensymphony.com/ognl/ rgds Don Brown <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: tm

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-06 Thread tm jee
sounds ok to me. But are we going to take it out in 2.1.x ? I'd prefer not to. rgds Matt Raible <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: +1 for restoring "do*". Matt On 11/6/06, Don Brown wrote: > tm jee wrote: > > Hi Vitor, > > > > I think the do fallback was removed from webwork. Have a look at > > http:

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-06 Thread Matt Raible
+1 for restoring "do*". Matt On 11/6/06, Don Brown <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: tm jee wrote: > Hi Vitor, > > I think the do fallback was removed from webwork. Have a look at http://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/WW/Key+Changes+From+WebWork+2 for more of the changes from webwork to struts2

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-06 Thread Don Brown
tm jee wrote: Hi Vitor, I think the do fallback was removed from webwork. Have a look at http://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/WW/Key+Changes+From+WebWork+2 for more of the changes from webwork to struts2. Yeah, I'm thinking we should put this back. Struts 2.0.x is about compatibili

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-06 Thread Don Brown
tm jee wrote: Hi guys, I think this option is mentioned before in Struts2 maling list (by Ted if not mistaken). What do you guys think about us forking Ognl? Ognl is just too important to WebWork/Struts2. Thoughts? Good? Bad Well, since we have full access to OGNL, why can't we just make

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-06 Thread tm jee
Hi guys, I think this option is mentioned before in Struts2 maling list (by Ted if not mistaken). What do you guys think about us forking Ognl? Ognl is just too important to WebWork/Struts2. Thoughts? Good? Bad? rgds Alexandru Popescu <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: On 11/6/06, Don Brown wrote:

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-06 Thread tm jee
Hi Vitor, I think the do fallback was removed from webwork. Have a look at http://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/WW/Key+Changes+From+WebWork+2 for more of the changes from webwork to struts2. > Or maybe I did something wrong and I'm totally embarassing myself right > now. No you are not.

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-06 Thread Alexandru Popescu
On 11/6/06, Don Brown <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Vitor Souza wrote: >> I'd love to have proper generics support in OGNL. If >> you create an OGNL >> patch, be sure to let the Struts dev list know so we >> can ensure it gets in. >> Don >> > > Don, > > I hacked OnglRuntime until it worked, but I d

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-06 Thread Vitor Souza
> Vitor Souza wrote: > > However, if you'd like I could create a JIRA (Bugzilla?) issue [...] > > > Yes, please create the ticket. Unfortunately, I don't believe there is > anyone left who _does_ have enough knowledge of OGNL > to truely vet it :( Ok. I will work on that. I will build a quick

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-06 Thread Don Brown
Vitor Souza wrote: I'd love to have proper generics support in OGNL. If you create an OGNL patch, be sure to let the Struts dev list know so we can ensure it gets in. Don Don, I hacked OnglRuntime until it worked, but I don't think I have enough knowledge of OGNL and Generics to say t

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-06 Thread Vitor Souza
> I'd love to have proper generics support in OGNL. If > you create an OGNL > patch, be sure to let the Struts dev list know so we > can ensure it gets in. > Don Don, I hacked OnglRuntime until it worked, but I don't think I have enough knowledge of OGNL and Generics to say that it would work

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-02 Thread Don Brown
I'd love to have proper generics support in OGNL. If you create an OGNL patch, be sure to let the Struts dev list know so we can ensure it gets in. Don Vitor Souza wrote: Just to complement the previous post, I quickly ported the application to Struts2 (by the way, it was VERY easy to do it!

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-01 Thread Don Brown
I think we can definitely say we will not be moving from OGNL for the Struts 2.0.x series, and most likely not for the Struts 2.1.x series. If we did try to move from OGNL for 2.1.x, it would probably still be the default, with the ability to switch OGNL for another EL for experimental purpose

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-01 Thread Alexandru Popescu
AFAIK, other projects have moved from OGNL usage. I am not gonna discuss if it is a good or bad decision, but in case we are gonna move away from it the old apps with heavy usage of OGNL will become more complex to be migrated. Unfortunately, I am not sure how we can find out what WW users have us

Re: Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-01 Thread Vitor Souza
Just to complement the previous post, I quickly ported the application to Struts2 (by the way, it was VERY easy to do it!) and removed my OgnlRuntime hack and it does cause the problem. The log file is here: http://labes.inf.ufes.br/~vitor/ww_ognl_issue/cookbook-struts.log The source code (Ecl

Will Struts2 use OGNL as WW did?

2006-11-01 Thread Vitor Souza
Hello there, Let's go straight to the question: will Struts2 continue to use OGNL as WebWork used to? Does that mean that OGNL will continue to be developed? Now to the long story... Sometime ago I posted a message at the OGNL forum. Here's the link: http://forums.opensymphony.com/thread.jspa?