Re: [HEADS-UP] Rawhide: /tmp is now on tmpfs

2012-06-20 Thread Chris Lumens
Again: I'm perfectly happy if it is rejected as a feature. I don't really care either way. What I'd really hate to see is a checkbox in the installer so we are compelled to test both variations... Yeah, I won't be adding any checkboxes to have people pick their /tmp style. - Chris -- devel

Re: Install Fedora Button for LiveCD

2012-05-03 Thread Chris Lumens
Yesterday night I noticed an IRC conversation on #fedora-desktop about this, and suggested that an actual window would be a lot better than a notification. Kalev, Matthias and the people there agreed with me, so I went ahead and wrote some code that does just that [1]. Screenshots can be

Re: Booting Fedora from LVM with grub2

2012-03-29 Thread Chris Lumens
Just out of curiosity: Your description makes me assume that the installer in the future still don't do things like partitioning, formating or installing a basic set of packages in the background while the user (which has a high latency/response time) is asked questions about the root

Re: Booting Fedora from LVM with grub2

2012-03-29 Thread Chris Lumens
Now my understanding of that doesn't include anything about removing custom partitioning. It's all about splitting up the functionality of anaconda into two distinct parts - the GUI configuration part, which I would expect still to contain custom partitioning, and a back-end that implements

Re: Booting Fedora from LVM with grub2

2012-03-29 Thread Chris Lumens
That's my understanding as well so it's not removing functionality but rather the underlying mechanism and implementation of them. This is good because it will allow a consistent outcome whether using the GUI, a kickstart file or something else like media and appliance creator and likely

Re: anaconda poor error handling

2011-11-09 Thread Chris Lumens
Just tried (and failed) update f15-f16. Using dvd (most reliable method). Went fine until I hit an error, trying to update ipython. At this point, anaconda just quit. No hints given what the issue was. No offer to try to report the error. It mentioned that it _might_ be caused by a

Re: What's this /run directory doing on my system and where does it come from?

2011-03-30 Thread Chris Lumens
I just uploaded a new version of systemd into F15, which establishes a directory /run in the root directory. Most likely you'll sooner or later stumble over it, so here's an explanation what this is and why this is. On behalf of everyone at anaconda, thanks for fixing something we've all

Re: Minimal install option (was Re: Services that can start by default policy feedback)

2011-02-25 Thread Chris Lumens
This was the same realization that led to the removal of the labeled minimal install, too many people just wanted to argue over the meaning of the term minimal. ? There's still a 'minimal' radio button in the installer at the package set selection stage. I know, I just clicked on it

Re: Plans for BTRFS in Fedora

2011-02-22 Thread Chris Lumens
1) Fedora 16 ships with BTRFS as the default root filesystem. 2) Fedora 16 ships without LVM as the volume manager and instead use BTRFS's built in volume management, again just for the default. 2) Anaconda support. I've already talked with Will Woods about this some. Really anaconda will

Re: Plans for BTRFS in Fedora

2011-02-22 Thread Chris Lumens
1) GRUB support. Edward Shishkin did GRUB1 patches for BTRFS a while ago, but they were obviously never merged upstream and were also not included into fedora. These would either need to be cleaned up and put into our grub package, or we'd need to put /boot on a different filesystem.

Re: [Test-Announce] Fedora 15 Alpha TC2 Available Now!

2011-02-15 Thread Chris Lumens
Hmm, also what does this do to PXE booting. IIRC there is a (relatively low) limit on the size of the initrd loaded by pxelinux. It's worked fine for me in all systems tested. - Chris -- devel mailing list devel@lists.fedoraproject.org https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/devel

Re: Fedora 15, new and exciting plans

2010-11-12 Thread Chris Lumens
* btrfs (Is this ready to be default? :) If so, would that warrant a change in our lvm by default setup? I don't think we are quite ready for this yet. I do have btrfs strategy on my todo list, though. I'm hoping we can start talking at FUDCon about what we want btrfs to do for us,

Re: Fedora 15, new and exciting plans

2010-11-12 Thread Chris Lumens
8f4340dc86f515cd2f6571c06b790ab420f719b2 Author: Chris Lumens clum...@redhat.com Date: Fri Sep 24 15:52:18 2010 -0400 btrfs will be a supported filesystem in F15 (josef). Overall, this sounds like a fine plan to me. - Chris -- devel mailing list devel@lists.fedoraproject.org https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo

Re: Anaconda suggestion...

2010-10-21 Thread Chris Lumens
So I'm in the process of upgrading (using preupgrade) from F13 to F14, something I typically do around the RC phase, anyway, that's beside the point. All the packages have been installed, but I'm at the point where I get Finishing upgrade process. This may take a little while and a

Re: Ubuntu 10.10's installer looks rather nice

2010-10-12 Thread Chris Lumens
Anaconda goes though everything step-by-step instead, asking one question after another, doing some work inbetween (partitining), asking more questions (packages to install) ... We have worked a little to reduce this over time, too. If you remember we used to have a confirmation screen

Re: Ubuntu 10.10's installer looks rather nice

2010-10-11 Thread Chris Lumens
Useless waste of time. Just grab Ubuntu iso and see a stunning gap in both technology and usability between anaconda and their own installed. Does the Ubuntu installer support installing to iscsi? Multipath? CCISS? Fully automated installation? Install over VNC? Installation from NFS, ISO

Re: Ubuntu 10.10's installer looks rather nice

2010-10-11 Thread Chris Lumens
- downloads updates in parallel too Package updates? - uses IP geolocation to guess the user's timezone and keyboard settings (it's been 100% correct for me each time) We can do this, it's just never really been brought up. I'd like to rework a lot of the l10n stuff anyway, there just

Re: Ubuntu 10.10's installer looks rather nice

2010-10-11 Thread Chris Lumens
Shipping 2 different installers is a recipe for disaster from a user and QA perspective.Choose one between Ubiquity, Debian-installer and Anaconda. We only ship one installer, and that is anaconda. I suppose you could argue over whether livecd is its own thing or not, but that's a nitpicky

Re: vesa-mode Anaconda install

2010-08-11 Thread Chris Lumens
Perhaps having a simple vesa arg to anaconda to force a vesa Xserver would provide a quick and simple work-around. It seems like this might be a simple hack to add to anaconda. A short-hand for xdriver=vesa Why do we need a shorthand for an argument you should only have to type once?

Re: [HEADS-UP] systemd for F14 - the next steps

2010-07-14 Thread Chris Lumens
Hmm, I wasn't aware that Anaconda even asks a question about the runlevel. Given that I am too lazy to try this out now, what exactly is this question? i.e. does it ask Are you installing a server or a deskop? or what does it ask? The default runlevel is inferred based upon packages installed

Re: suggestion: rescue boot extension

2010-06-03 Thread Chris Lumens
Rescue environment aside, it'd be nice to avoid failing the upgrade because of insufficient space in /boot. I think 200 MB default /boot prove to be too small---perhaps 500 MB should be the new default? Of course, it already is:

Re: PackageKit need to be more intelligent!

2010-05-12 Thread Chris Lumens
users do not need to find devel packages from the PackageKit GUI, we need to search useful packages from here, that is my opinion... This line of thinking needs to stop. Developers are users, too, and development packages ending up in the search results is not such a bad thing. Those packages

Re: Board efforts: scope, concept, and permission?

2010-02-03 Thread Chris Lumens
Would it be possible to put spin kickstarts on the common install DVD, with an option in anaconda to choose them (and notes that network access may be required for some packages)? This would give an easier way to install alternate spins, without having to download and burn lots of CDs, boot,