Re: [IxDA Discuss] IxD in government

2008-10-12 Thread dnp607
Hi William, I work as a contractor at NASA and have also spent some years on DHS projects in the past. As far as I know, it's quite rare to find positions marked with this specific career goal. At NASA it's not titled "Interaction Design" per se, rather, Human Factors. NASA has done a tr

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Do you regard "Interaction Design" as good namefor your design practice? else, what's your prefer?

2008-10-12 Thread J. Scot Angus
I prefer User Experience Strategist. Sometimes I'm doing IA, sometimes IxD, sometimes visual design... sometimes even working with the back- end crew because, as we all know, a poorly executed back-end can *also* precipitate bad user experiences. There are many ways to skin a cat (and I cert

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Research supplier near Palo Alto

2008-10-12 Thread Elizabeth Bacon
Ack, my URLs seem to have been edited out. They were: Fleischman Field Research http://www.ffrsf.com/ Fieldwork http://www.fieldwork.com/Facility/Home.aspx?FacilityID=33 Bay Area Research Group http://bayarearesearchgroup.com/New Site/Welcome.html Nichols Research http://www.nicholsresearch.co

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Research supplier near Palo Alto

2008-10-12 Thread Elizabeth Bacon
Hey folks, Thanks for all who wrote with research supplier recommendations. I wanted to share all four for your future reference (see below). FWIW, Fleischman responded to me promptly with a bid, as did Fieldwork; Bay Area Research Group didn't get back to me as promised (and they have to coordina

Re: [IxDA Discuss] How to represent overlapping objects

2008-10-12 Thread Martin
A good example that springs to mind is Google Earth. If you have multiple data layers enabled such that there are multiple data for a single location (e.g., a Wikipedia entry and a Panoramio photo), when you click the icon for a place, it animates out into a several distinct objects linked hub-and-

Re: [IxDA Discuss] How to represent overlapping objects

2008-10-12 Thread William Brall
While computationally troublesome, I really like Paul's ideas. As a compromise if they prove to require too much JS to be smooth, have the markers be two different colors, one for rollover and one for not and make them all transparent at around 10-30% Great ideas Paul! Will . . . . . . . . .

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Do you regard "Interaction Design" as good name for your design practice? else, what's your prefer?

2008-10-12 Thread Uso Design // Bernardo van de Schepop
I pretty much like the inversion. Intead of Interaction Design, I use Design for Interaction. In that way I feel confortable to explain it further in whatever context. Nowadays I am designing hardware interfaces, before I worked with software and internet services, mainly with interface design and

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Do you regard "Interaction Design" as good namefor your design practice? else, what's your prefer?

2008-10-12 Thread Ken Mohnkern
For Jack's reasons I go with Interaction Designer. "Architect" sounds like an analog rather than what I actually do. In fact, I sometimes describe what I do as analogous to an architect. I'll also use terms like "user experience" in my explanations, which makes people say "Oh - user friendly!" "Ye

Re: [IxDA Discuss] How to represent overlapping objects

2008-10-12 Thread Paul Eisen
Iram asked: > I am designing a map feature where there may be several objects that can > overlap. Anyone have any suggestions on how best to indicate overlapping > items? Some of the options are using the indicators similar to the ones used > in Google Maps, or pins. One option: How about adding a

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Gathering Data from Training

2008-10-12 Thread Catriona Macaulay
Hi William Thanks for a thoughtful response. Let me pick up a few threads... On 12 Oct 2008, at 12:39, William Brall wrote: I have my own issues with agile, which I'm going to avoid getting into. I think anyone who has ever worked in any capacity on an agile project has their issues wit

Re: [IxDA Discuss] ACD/UCD Round Two

2008-10-12 Thread William Brall
Christina, This is why these methods are great for teaching. They show the young people the core things to do in a framework that is something of a road-map. Do this, you'll get here. It will instill good practices: Goal-mindset versus Task/Feature-mindset Persona/Archetypes versus Panels of use

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Gathering Data from Training

2008-10-12 Thread William Brall
Catriona, I have my own issues with agile, which I'm going to avoid getting into. I find it interesting that you claim your projects for scientists can't be well designed just because of the nature of the product, on that I disagree. No software is going to be instantly understandable, which seem

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Gathering Data from Training

2008-10-12 Thread Catriona Macaulay
Hi Bojhan Your story sounds very familiar - I work on an agile open source development project in the scientific software world. To respond to William's point, designing a phone interface that needs minimal training is a realistic goal, designing collaborative imaging management and analysis softw

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Gathering Data from Training

2008-10-12 Thread Andy Edmonds
I'd recommend instrumenting with web analytics your training application usage. While it's not a completely controlled scenario, materials at least tend to be consistent and users are given tasks at various stages of experience with the product. You should be able to identify persistent user e

Re: [IxDA Discuss] ACD/UCD Round Two

2008-10-12 Thread Christina Wodtke
After listening to this debate (thank you all kindly) I suspect the urge to discard the term is because many designers have been doing it "wrong." Forms of that might be * user centered design rather than users centered design-- making too many decisions off of a small subset of users who may vary

Re: [IxDA Discuss] ACD/UCD Round Two

2008-10-12 Thread William Brall
I think we are getting hung up on terms here. In the end it all means the same thing. You aren't are programmer designing for yourself a thing that does what the users need. As long as you aren't that, you'll do a decent job of making your product usable. Most of these methods are philosophical,

Re: [IxDA Discuss] ACD/UCD Round Two

2008-10-12 Thread mark schraad
This will not answer your questions directly Jared, but I think it is at the heart of the issue. I read and hear people daily that question the validity and worth of research. The link they distrust the most is that interpretation. I heard an exec recently request process that eliminates hu

Re: [IxDA Discuss] ACD/UCD Round Two

2008-10-12 Thread Will Evans
I'm sure you will. We all await with baited breath your razor sharp intellect to cut though this issue like a hot knife through buttah. On Sun, Oct 12, 2008 at 8:46 AM, Jared Spool <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Ok. I've unburied myself from conference preparations enough to begin to > seriously de

Re: [IxDA Discuss] ACD/UCD Round Two

2008-10-12 Thread Jared Spool
Ok. I've unburied myself from conference preparations enough to begin to seriously deal with this silliness. I'm working on my you-guys-are- thinking-all-wrong rebuttal, but there's one clarification I need. Robert wrote: 4. UCD = users are unreliable, unstable, and often unpredictable; ACD