[slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-01-28 Thread MrC
Enjoy the read: http://www.laptoplogic.com/reviews/detail.php?id=190&part=glance -- MrC MrC's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=468 View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=4

Re: [slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-01-28 Thread bigfool1956
Nice review, not one mention of how it actually sounds. -- bigfool1956 David Ayers Music is what counts, hifi just helps us enjoy it more bigfool1956's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=13782 Vi

Re: [slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-01-28 Thread simonsays
I beg to differ as I wrote that review: Operating everywhere from 20 feet to one and half floors away – the quality of audio was directly related to what the file was set at. Some extremely high bitrate (320kb) started to drop when I tested the unit a floor and a half away, but that’s only becaus

Re: [slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-01-28 Thread MuckleEck
Interesting review, most of which is about setting up networks, not something I have ever had an issue with at home, I didn't need to open ports on my router or firewallsunless I was accessing the slimserver from the internet...does everybody lock their firewalls down even on their 192.168.x.x

Re: [slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-01-29 Thread aubuti
simonsays;263491 Wrote: > For compressed format was also sounding great – but not as great as the > uncompressed (naturally). I'll confess that I haven't read the review yet, but I'll mention that you might want to be more careful with your distinctions here. The issue for sound quality isn't com

Re: [slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-01-29 Thread Peter
simonsays wrote: > I beg to differ as I wrote that review: > I don't understand why you added all that stuff about port forwarding and opening ports. That kind of thing is only needed if you want to connect to slimserver from another location on the internet (outside your home). Something re

Re: [slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-01-29 Thread maggior
Peter;263525 Wrote: > simonsays wrote: > > I beg to differ as I wrote that review: > > > > I don't understand why you added all that stuff about port forwarding > and opening ports. That kind of thing is only needed if you want to > connect to slimserver from another location on the interne

Re: [slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-01-29 Thread Pale Blue Ego
A few criticisms about the review. I don't think I've seen even a networking novice have so much trouble setting up the SB3. Most people have it running in 10 minutes, especially if they've spent a little time setting up SlimServer while waiting for the SB3 hardware to arrive. And what's with a

Re: [slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-01-29 Thread bigfool1956
Aha, got fooled by the site not following de facto standards about multi page articles (i.e. page 1 2 3 ...) and didn't click next, assuming that would be the next article. Oh well, I take back what I said about no mention of how it sounds. -- bigfool1956 David Ayers Music is what counts, hif

Re: [slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-01-30 Thread MuckleEck
I was also fooled by the next pageread that and one thing that strikes me is the comment that "this relies on a a wireless network" which is not correct, there is always the option of using the wired network. -- MuckleEck Alasdair 3 SB3s - AudioEngine 2 - Cambridge Audio 640R - Mordaunt

Re: [slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-02-23 Thread simonsays
Great feedback, and like I stated - there is the option for regular ethernet connection. BUT, this is marketed as a "wireless streaming device" - so that's what the article is geared towards. I run high security on my laptop, router NAT, and Yoggie Pico security device - port forwarding MUST occ

Re: [slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-02-23 Thread amcluesent
>If you are not worried about firewall settings, that's your data. Not mine.< IMHO you should state in your review that you're running an unusual set-up with a h/w firewall just for the laptop. You leave the impression that every user will have experience you had. Setting up an SB takes 2 mins t

Re: [slim] Squeezebox review: Laptop Logic

2008-02-24 Thread bl243
I agree with amcluesent, the complications of the network setup are of your own making in order to maintain the security you want to achieve, and the end result is the reader thinking they will have to do the same and being put off. I have no issue with enforcing high levels of security - it is c