Re: [Discuss-gnuradio] [GSoC2018][Standard FEC Decoders][Need Feedback]

2018-03-26 Thread Johannes Demel
Hi Harshit, some more comments on your proposal. - be really specific about GR integration - explain WHAT you want to implement. - explain HOW you want to implement it. - show us how you understand FECAPI. - explain how you want to build on existing LDPC code in GR. your deliverables are too

Re: [Discuss-gnuradio] [GSoC2018][Standard FEC Decoders][Need Feedback]

2018-03-24 Thread Harshit Gupta
Greetings, Thanks Demel for the detailed feedback. I have updated most of the parts. Please have a look [0] and report for any ambiguity. [0] https://github.com/harshit4084/MyDoc/blob/master/gsoc2018_Harshit_Gupta.pdf

Re: [Discuss-gnuradio] [GSoC2018][Standard FEC Decoders][Need Feedback]

2018-03-23 Thread Johannes Demel
Hi Harshit, I read your proposal and I have quite a few suggestions for improvement. General remarks Your references must be updated. They do not point to the actual sources but some general landing page. Also, I found at least one reference that points to an incorrect source. Introduction

Re: [Discuss-gnuradio] [GSoC2018][Standard FEC Decoders][Need Feedback]

2018-03-23 Thread Harshit Gupta
Hello everyone, The link was pointing to an older version. I have fixed the link. I need some feedback on my proposal [0]. Some queries: What exactly should I include in 'Implementation'? I have put generic decoder code and sample code for optimal implementation of FEC codes (specifically LDPC).

Re: [Discuss-gnuradio] [GSoC2018][Standard FEC Decoders][Need Feedback]

2018-03-22 Thread CEL
I don't understand – you still haven't addressed any of the mandatory things that I complained were missing. Since having all the formal requirements and information and specified on the wiki page is a **requirement**, we can't work with the proposal in its current shape! Best regards, Marcus

Re: [Discuss-gnuradio] [GSoC2018][Standard FEC Decoders][Need Feedback]

2018-03-22 Thread Harshit Gupta
Greeting Mr Muller and community, I have made improvement in the proposal. Have a glimpse of it, Some queries: What exactly should I include in 'Implementation'? I have put generic decoder code and sample code for optimal implementation of FEC codes. What can be the outcome of a specific

Re: [Discuss-gnuradio] [GSoC2018][Standard FEC Decoders][Need Feedback]

2018-03-22 Thread CEL
Hi Harshit Gupta, thanks for showing up and being interested in GNU Radio! I'm very happy that someone with an information theory background decided to give channel code implementations a try. From a quick scan of the proposal, I'd say that you have not adhered to all the mandatory things on

[Discuss-gnuradio] [GSoC2018][Standard FEC Decoders][Need Feedback]

2018-03-22 Thread Harshit Gupta
Greetings, My name is Harshit Gupta, graduated in Electrical Engineering. Currently pursuing masters from Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi. Having studied information theory in my post-graduate coursework, I can understand FEC codes in a better manner. I want to contribute to GNU Radio with