Re: Stalled tickets

2019-09-27 Thread Adam Johnson
our opinion and starting this discussion. > Project governance decisions like this are often implicit or dictated by > tradition, so it's worth revisiting them occasionally! > > On 19-09-26 16:42:25, David Vaz wrote: > >So if we would decide to close stalled tickets after some inacti

Re: Stalled tickets

2019-09-27 Thread Tobias Kunze
Hi David, first off: thank you for voicing your opinion and starting this discussion. Project governance decisions like this are often implicit or dictated by tradition, so it's worth revisiting them occasionally! On 19-09-26 16:42:25, David Vaz wrote: >So if we would decide to close stal

Re: Stalled tickets

2019-09-27 Thread Peter van der Does
djangoproject.com/query?status=assigned=new=09%2F26%2F2017..09%2F26%2F2019=Accepted>: >   > 494 > > Modified in last year > <https://code.djangoproject.com/query?status=assigned=new=09%2F26%2F2018..09%2F26%2F2019=Accepted>: >   >    329 > > > So if we would decide to close stalled t

Re: Stalled tickets

2019-09-27 Thread Carlton Gibson
728 > > Modified in last 2 years > <https://code.djangoproject.com/query?status=assigned=new=09%2F26%2F2017..09%2F26%2F2019=Accepted>: > > 494 > > Modified in last year > <https://code.djangoproject.com/query?status=assigned=new=09%2F26%2F2018..09%2F26%2F2019=Acce

Re: Stalled tickets

2019-09-27 Thread Virgílio Santos
Hello, I'm looking for someone to walk me through a fast path to getting active on the community and start solving tickets! I know there is a lot of docs, but it will be extra time of my working day, so it will be very nice to be somehow mentored through delivering than reading lots of docs!

Re: Stalled tickets

2019-09-27 Thread Mariusz Felisiak
I'm also strongly against closing an "idle" tickets. Sometimes tickets are solved after many years (even 9, 10, or more). Age doesn't make them less valid. In "open tickets scale" 4-5 years is not a long time. Closing tickets just because they're old or because we would like to get a better

Re: Stalled tickets

2019-09-27 Thread Elena Williams
com/elena/> On Fri, 27 Sep 2019 at 19:32, Adam Johnson wrote: > I'm also not sure of the value of closing stalled tickets. Closing them > makes them less visible, and as Claude says, they're still valid. Often I > find one that's been open years has "come up again" on the mail

Re: Stalled tickets

2019-09-27 Thread Adam Johnson
I'm also not sure of the value of closing stalled tickets. Closing them makes them less visible, and as Claude says, they're still valid. Often I find one that's been open years has "come up again" on the mailing list or client work. The fellows are the ones who work the most with

Re: Stalled tickets

2019-09-27 Thread Claude Paroz
Sorry but I would *strongly* oppose any idea of closing a ticket because noone commented in the last x years. Most of those tickets are still valid issues, but they remain open because noone dedicated the appropriate time to solve them, sometimes because the problem is a corner case, sometimes

Re: Stalled tickets

2019-09-27 Thread ludovic coues
19=Accepted>: > 494 > > Modified in last year > <https://code.djangoproject.com/query?status=assigned=new=09%2F26%2F2018..09%2F26%2F2019=Accepted>: >329 > > > So if we would decide to close stalled tickets after some inactivity > period we could massivel

Stalled tickets

2019-09-26 Thread David Vaz
;: 329 So if we would decide to close stalled tickets after some inactivity period we could massively reduce the opened tickets list. Imagine if we close any ticket no modified in the last 5 years we would reduce by 20% the active ticket list. If we decide to be more aggressive, say 3