Re: Boston Globe: MCAS results show weakness in teens' grasp

2001-08-25 Thread dennis roberts
At 07:35 PM 8/25/01 +, EugeneGall wrote: > The answer hinges only on a trivial choice made by Tukey >when he described the boxplot. Incidentally, Tufte criticized the lack of >information in the box width in the Tukey boxplot and proposed an alternative. i don't think this is relevant to t

Re: Boston Globe: MCAS results show weakness in teens' grasp of

2001-08-25 Thread dennis roberts
conceptually yes ... since, some items are clearly more important than others ... empirically ... since this has been explored many times ... back in the 70s and 80s ... it seems to have no impact on rel and val ... who decides? well, one way is to say ... experts ... have them rate items in

Re: Boston Globe: MCAS results show weakness in teens' grasp

2001-08-25 Thread EugeneGall
>From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] (dennis roberts) >the only purpose it can serve ... and i am not saying this is important . >is to know that the median is part of a boxplot ... just like you might >want them to identify what the | are at the ends ... the hinges ... just as >you might want them to kno

Re: Boston Globe: MCAS results show weakness in teens' grasp of

2001-08-25 Thread RCKnodt
In a message dated 8/25/01 9:06:18 AM Pacific Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: << whether the item you talk about rises to the level of being important enough ... i am not sure ... certainly, in the overall scheme of things ... IF it is included ... it would have to be considered to

Methodologic Conference on Health Policy Research

2001-08-25 Thread fharrell
The following conference is sponsored by the Health Policy Statistics Section of the American Statistical Association. If anyone has questions about this conference please reply to [EMAIL PROTECTED] Thanks- Frank Harrell The "2001 Inter

Re: Boston Globe: MCAS results show weakness in teens' grasp of

2001-08-25 Thread dennis roberts
the only purpose it can serve ... and i am not saying this is important ... is to know that the median is part of a boxplot ... just like you might want them to identify what the | are at the ends ... the hinges ... just as you might want them to know that the whisker has 25% in it ... at each

Re: Boston Globe: MCAS results show weakness in teens' grasp of

2001-08-25 Thread EugeneGall
Some of the MCAS stats and probability questions were tough but fair. I disagreed vehemently with one question: Question 39 on the 10th grade Math 2001 test. It showed a Tukey boxplot and asked whether the graph represented a mean and range or a median and range. Now, this question will do one

++ Today Is The Day !! ++ 2 4824

2001-08-25 Thread 2todaytheday4569038
Title: Limited Time Offer! As seen on NBC, CBS, CNN, and even Oprah! The health dis