[EM] True Ranked Choice - for Condorcet

2010-08-23 Thread Kathy Dopp
Dave, I like all your ideas here. It is amazing that people continue to misinform by making the false claim that IRV finds majority winners and solves the spoiler problem, when IRV does neither, and in fact fails more of Arrow's fairness criteria than plurality voting by exhibiting nonmonotonicit

Re: [EM] True Ranked Choice - for Condorcet

2010-08-23 Thread Kristofer Munsterhjelm
Dave Ketchum wrote: I see below that leeswalker is doing his best for IRV. Would be useful if some of us could do better for Condorcet - which I see as a competitor that should win. TRC - True Ranked Choice - my thought for a possible label for Condorcet, based on: Like IRV, let's vot

Re: [EM] True Ranked Choice - for Condorcet

2010-08-23 Thread Dave Ketchum
If someone can do better, fine. I DO argue that such as Burlington demonstrate TRC doing better than IRV at truly seeing voter desires. On Aug 23, 2010, at 2:38 PM, robert bristow-johnson wrote: On Aug 23, 2010, at 1:53 PM, Dave Ketchum wrote: I see below that leeswalker is doing his best f

[EM] True Ranked Choice - for Condorcet

2010-08-23 Thread Dave Ketchum
I see below that leeswalker is doing his best for IRV. Would be useful if some of us could do better for Condorcet - which I see as a competitor that should win. TRC - True Ranked Choice - my thought for a possible label for Condorcet, based on: Like IRV, let's voters rank their choi