Re: [EM] Craig: I did include ballot-counting code

2005-02-02 Thread Russ Paielli
For anyone who needs "ballot-counting code," I suggest you try my Graphical Voter Interface (GVI), which you can find at http://ElectionMethods.org/GVI.htm . GVI is professional-quality software that goes way beyond a command-line interface. It is close to usable in a real public election. Scre

[EM] Lottery Methods

2005-02-02 Thread Forest Simmons
Recently Jobst introduced us to the idea of electing a "lottery" that, in turn, picks the winner. Here's one way that idea could be applied to the obstreperous ballot set 49 C 24 B 27 A>B : First we introduce the lotteries A', B', and C' : A' means a toss up between B and C. B' means a toss u

Re: [EM] Comparative Effectiveness of Approval and Condorcet in the case of a three candidate cycle.

2005-02-02 Thread Russ Paielli
Forest Simmons simmonfo-at-up.edu |EMlist| wrote: Russ brought up the issue of effectiveness of Approval. I think that we are mostly in agreement now that Approval locks on to the CW fairly quickly when there is a CW. "Quickly" can even mean during the first election if DSV is used, or if partia

Re: MIKE OSSIPOFF vs The list (Re: [EM] I didn't choose to be the topic

2005-02-02 Thread Markus Schulze
Hallo, Example 4: 10 ABCD 15 BACD 20 CABD 3 ABCD Suppose Craig Carey's IFPP method is being used. In the first round, the quota is 12. D is eliminated in the first round. In the second round, the quota is 16 so that A and B are eliminated and C wins. When 7 C voters

[EM] Re: simulating an Approval campaign/election

2005-02-02 Thread Rob LeGrand
Forest wrote: > Actually, DSV with Strategy A can sometimes converge to a stable > equilibrium even when there is no Condorcet Winner: > > 4900 C > 2400 B > 2700 A>B You're right. I forgot to disclose my assumption of strict preferences. A better way to say what I meant: When for every candidat

[EM] Re: simulating an Approval campaign/election

2005-02-02 Thread Forest Simmons
From: Rob LeGrand <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [EM] Re: simulating an Approval campaign/election Russ wrote: You seem to have confirmed my hypothesis that, in the idealized case (DSV batch mode), Approval voting almost always converges on the Cordorcet winner if one exists, but rarely (never?) conv

[EM] Re: Election-methods Digest, Vol 8, Issue 4

2005-02-02 Thread William Redpath
Please unsubscribe me from this list. - Original Message - From: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Wednesday, February 02, 2005 3:06 PM Subject: Election-methods Digest, Vol 8, Issue 4 Send Election-methods mailing list submissions to election-methods-electorama.com@electorama.com To subscr