At 08:58 PM 5/12/2005, Curt Siffert wrote:
I recently posted this addendum to the Arrow's Theorem page on
wikipedia: It was immediately deleted for "bias". [...]
Was I out in left field for writing this?
Have you asked in the comment page attached to the article? Another writer
here pointed out
Curt Siffert wrote:
[...] In other words, some vote theorists believe Arrow's
theorem improperly asserts that passing the IIAC is a requirement to be
considered a satisfactory voting method. [...]
I can't speak for the theorists, but that's not how I read Arrow's
theorum. For one thing, he pr
I recently posted this addendum to the Arrow's Theorem page on wikipedia: It was immediately deleted for "bias".
"The theorem is criticized by many vote theorists, however, for depending on flawed requirements. [...] It is the final (IIAC) criterion that is most controversial. Some vote theori
