RE: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-26 Thread Gustav Wikström
Hi, > -Original Message- > From: Roland Everaert > Sent: den 23 december 2019 14:32 > To: Gustav Wikström > Cc: emacs-orgmode@gnu.org > Subject: Re: [Idea] Org Collections > Have you had a look at org-brain. I don't use is much, but there are some > overlapping

Re: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-23 Thread Roland Everaert
Gustav Wikström writes: > Hi! > >> -Original Message- >> From: Emacs-orgmode On Behalf >> Of Roland Everaert >> Sent: den 16 december 2019 12:26 >> To: emacs-orgmode@gnu.org >> Subject: Re: [Idea] Org Collections >> >> +1 f

Re: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-16 Thread William Denton
On 14 December 2019, Gustav Wikström wrote: 2 Idea == I propose to introduce `Collection' as a concept in the realm of Org mode. [1] This is very interesting, and I think I have some cases where I could use this. When there's something to test, I'll certainly try it. It's a good

RE: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-16 Thread Gustav Wikström
Hi! > -Original Message- > From: Emacs-orgmode On Behalf > Of Roland Everaert > Sent: den 16 december 2019 12:26 > To: emacs-orgmode@gnu.org > Subject: Re: [Idea] Org Collections > > +1 for this idea. > > You speak about one document used by multiple

Re: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-16 Thread Roland Everaert
I do agree that "aspect" is a very abstract term and all depends on the scope of this proposal, I suppose. Reading the proposal again, it seems that my proposal could apply, as the intent seems to define a per "aspect" configuration. On the other end as aspects are quite abstract, an aspect can

Re: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-16 Thread Tim Cross
I would have to say the hardest thing I ever have to do as a developer is naming things. It is hard enough to do within a context of a single group, even harder when speaking about something with a global user base (language, social/cultural differences etc). Despite this, it is so very

Re: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-16 Thread Roland Everaert
+1 for this idea. You speak about one document used by multiple collections, how do you plan to manage that from a file system point of view? How will be organized a collection, still from the FS point of view? As some are delving into the abyss of sementic, I propose aspects instead of

Re: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-16 Thread Christian Moe
+1, that is: This is an interesting idea, there have been times when I might have found something like this handy, and I might well use if it's developed, though I'm not sure if it will ease my cognitive load or add to it. :-) Yours, Christian Moe Gustav Wikström writes: [...]

RE: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-15 Thread Gustav Wikström
. And haven’t thought that there should be a syntax for that either. But please explain more on what you think, if I misunderstood you! /Gustav From: John Sturdy Sent: den 15 december 2019 13:14 To: Gustav Wikström Cc: emacs-orgmode@gnu.org Subject: Re: [Idea] Org Collections That seems

RE: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-15 Thread Gustav Wikström
Hi Adam, > -Original Message- > From: Emacs-orgmode On > Behalf Of Adam Porter > Sent: den 15 december 2019 12:01 > To: emacs-orgmode@gnu.org > Subject: Re: [Idea] Org Collections > > How does this idea compare with Akira Komamura's org-starter package? >

RE: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-15 Thread Gustav Wikström
be better. But not sure yet how to realize it. Thinking in progress. Thanks Gustav From: Emacs-orgmode On Behalf Of tbanelwebmin Sent: den 15 december 2019 10:08 To: emacs-orgmode@gnu.org Subject: Re: [Idea] Org Collections Interesting idea! Is everyone aware of Emacs Projectile? https

Re: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-15 Thread John Sturdy
That seems hierarchical, which is ok (as in org-mode itself) but how about implementing a more general graph mechanism, which could be used to do this but more flexibly? On Sat, 14 Dec 2019, 21:04 Gustav Wikström, wrote: > Hi list and all honored readers! > > I have an idea. One that I've

Re: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-15 Thread Adam Porter
How does this idea compare with Akira Komamura's org-starter package? https://github.com/akirak/org-starter Its readme begins: > Org-starter is a framework for basic configuration of Emacs Org > Mode. It allows you to configure Org Mode easily even with many files > and directories. > The

Re: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-15 Thread tbanelwebmin
Interesting idea! Is everyone aware of Emacs Projectile? https://github.com/bbatsov/projectile Not exactly the Org Collections you talks about, Gustav, but somehow related. Projectile manages collections of files that belong

Re: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-14 Thread Eric Abrahamsen
Tim Cross writes: [...] > Its a +1 from me. And me -- I use Org across so many different contexts (in fact, I'd propose the name org-contexts over org-collections \end{bikeshed}), sometimes using the /same data in different contexts/, and while Org has good tools for localizing config

Re: [Idea] Org Collections

2019-12-14 Thread Tim Cross
In general, I like the idea. While you are correct that most of what you refer to can be achieved using existing org functionality, I like the clear separation 'collections' would offer - it is like a namespace for a collection of org documents. I like the idea of being able to isolate