Re: [PSES] Single Point Grounding - Not Achievable at High Frequencies (greater than a few MHz)

2013-05-21 Thread John Woodgate
In message <1369188828.49145.yahoomail...@web160402.mail.bf1.yahoo.com>, dated Tue, 21 May 2013, Bill Owsley writes: It is the definition of zero impedance since there can be none lower. I think that is the point; it's NOT zero. It may be the lowest obtainable but it is still finite and the

Re: [PSES] Capacitor Discharge Test IEC 61010-1

2013-05-21 Thread Bill Owsley
A few decades ago when an intern, called co-op back then, a customer complaint came in that they had been shocked by the power plug after pulling it from the wall.  No way said the engineers!  Hey co-op go test this.  We  it turns out there can be the peak voltage left on the pins of the

Re: [PSES] safety 60950 and surge suppression circuits

2013-05-21 Thread Bill Owsley
So the Safety engineer said the single fault condition was an open ground... Now what? A surge into a 300 volt SPD transfers that surge voltage to the open ground (chassis) and there is now a hazard !!! Thus the position, I've been told while sticking my fingers in my ears, The SPD's have to als

Re: [PSES] Single Point Grounding - Not Achievable at High Frequencies (greater than a few MHz)

2013-05-21 Thread Bill Owsley
Ahh...  the common convolted and complex analysis discussing the issue with complicated explanationsand rationalizations. I may be way off in this, but it seems to work. So take a unit square of ground plane, or power plane, or reference plane, or whatever plane you'd like to call the intended re

Re: [PSES] Single Point Grounding - Not Achievable at High Frequencies (greater than a few MHz)

2013-05-21 Thread Bill Owsley
dang you beat me too it.  I thought this would evolve over several notes, but no... you had to go all the way at once. I was going to go from single point, expanded to a single edge, expended to a plane, which can again be expanded to a chassis, and with care on cable shield terminations, to sin

Re: [PSES] safety 60950 and surge suppression circuits

2013-05-21 Thread Joe Randolph
Hi Scott: Your explanation makes sense but it presumes the SPD shunts the current to ground.  It would appear to me that the SPD is allowed to simply bridge the isolation barrier.  That is the aspect that seems contradictory to me.  In 60950-1 clauses 6.1.2 and 6.2 (the ones I work with most fr

Re: [PSES] safety 60950 and surge suppression circuits

2013-05-21 Thread Aldous, Scott
Throwing in my 2 cents: Hipot test values are based on expected transients. The concern with the transient overvoltages is that they could punch through insulation needed for safety and subsequently hazardous voltages can be allowed to reach areas where they should not. The function of an SPD i

Re: [PSES] safety 60950 and surge suppression circuits

2013-05-21 Thread Peter Tarver
Rich - Notwithstanding your statements about the safety insulation needing to meet the testing, I have always viewed the testing with the SPC removed or disabled to be an allowance, since in almost every instance, will cause a false indication of breakdown of the safety insulation by means of fulf

Re: [PSES] safety 60950 and surge suppression circuits

2013-05-21 Thread Joe Randolph
Hi Rich: The apparent contradiction that I was trying to describe can be summarized as follows: a) The safety insulation barrier must withstand a hipot test of, say, 1500 VRMS b) It is permissible to bridge this safety insulation barrier with a SPD that breaks down at, say, 300 VRMS In other word

[PSES] Capacitor Discharge Test IEC 61010-1

2013-05-21 Thread Kunde, Brian
What we call the Capacitor Discharge Test in the IEC 61010-1 standard section 6.10.3 says that voltage across the pins of the power cord must not be Hazardous Live 5 seconds after disconnection from the supply. Most labs simply check to see if the voltage across the pins are 60 volts or less at

Re: [PSES] safety 60950 and surge suppression circuits

2013-05-21 Thread Mick Maytum
Rich, Given your rational that surge protective components (SPCs), such as MOVs or GDTs, can have a fault mode anywhere between a short-circuit and an open-circuit, looks like there is a disconnect in the test levels. In the open-circuit situation, the SPC does not divert current and t

Re: [PSES] Single Point Grounding - Not Achievable at High Frequencies (greater than a few MHz)

2013-05-21 Thread John Woodgate
In message , dated Tue, 21 May 2013, "ce-test, qualified testing bv - Gert Gremmen" writes: In RF technology it is very common to use a plane as a single grounding point. It isn't a single point; it may be a close approach to a single point but I have seen trouble even at audio frequencies

Re: [PSES] Single Point Grounding - Not Achievable at High Frequencies (greater than a few MHz)

2013-05-21 Thread John Woodgate
In message <1369105334.30674.yahoomail...@web160401.mail.bf1.yahoo.com>, dated Mon, 20 May 2013, Bill Owsley writes: Dr. Tom Van Doren demonstrates that single point grounding is not possible above the audio frequencies.  Thus the lower cutoff in the "regulations" of 9 kHz.  And that is reall