[Emu] Re: Last call comments:draft-williams-on-channel-binding-01.txt: EAP chann

2007-04-07 Thread Bernard Aboba
This is something that IEEE 802.11r/D5.0 is doing. R0KH-ID is set to the identity of the NAS Client (e.g., NAS-Identifier if RADIUS is used as the backend protocol) and this identifier is sent to the peer during association (before EAP authentication). In addition, both the R0KH-ID (NAS-Identifier

Re: [Emu] Last call comments: draft-williams-on-channel-binding-01.txt: EAP channel bindings

2007-04-07 Thread Jouni Malinen
On Sat, Apr 07, 2007 at 04:44:54PM -0400, Charles Clancy wrote: > This is one of the fundamental issues with EAP channel bindings. The > NAS ID is bound to the AAA security association between the > authenticator and the EAP server. The MAC address is visible to the > client. Thus the peer a

RE: [Emu] Re: Thoughts on Password-based EAP Methods

2007-04-07 Thread Bernard Aboba
I'm glad to hear from Steve here that there is support for publishing TTLSv0. I would like to see that happen regardless of whether it is done as an EMU work item or not. My understanding is that a new version of the TTLSv0 document will be forthcoming which will fill in some of the details tha

RE: [Emu] Re: Thoughts on Password-based EAP Methods

2007-04-07 Thread Narayanan, Vidya
I share the concerns expressed about defining yet another password based EAP method. As people have pointed out here, EAP-TTLSv0 also allows the use of the TLS record layer to carry a password-based authentication method without an inner tunneling of EAP. Several months ago, I tried contacting Pa

Re: [Emu] Last call comments: draft-williams-on-channel-binding-01.txt: EAP channel bindings

2007-04-07 Thread Charles Clancy
Sam Hartman wrote: "Charles" == Charles Clancy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: Charles> I don't think I'm convinced that EAP channel bindings are Charles> doing this binding to the L2 channel. The identity used Charles> in an EAP channel binding must be bound to the AAA Charles> s

RE: [Emu] Talk on Windows EAP implementation...

2007-04-07 Thread Glen Zorn \(gwz\)
I thought folks on these two lists might be interested in this, Microsoft will be having a web chat next week discussing its EAP platform if you want to know more about our implementation and how you can integrate with it this is probably a interesting talk. See: http://blogs.technet.com/nap/ar