Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-31 Thread Lee Hart via EV
EVDL Administrator via EV wrote: Lee Hart via EV wrote: I had a 1980 C-car. Its charger was pretty crude, but it was a little more than this... http://www.evdl.org/docs/c_car_charger.jpg Yep; that's it! :-) This circuit is in my 1973 GE SCR manual, and goes back even further than that (GE Ap

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-31 Thread David Nelson via EV
On Sun, May 31, 2015 at 10:35 PM, EVDL Administrator via EV wrote: > On 31 May 2015 at 22:48, Lee Hart via EV wrote: > >> In this case, the ComutaCar charger is *not* voltage regulated, nor >> current limited, nor is there any shut-off timer. It is nothing but a >> big transformer and rectifier. >

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-31 Thread EVDL Administrator via EV
On 31 May 2015 at 22:48, Lee Hart via EV wrote: > In this case, the ComutaCar charger is *not* voltage regulated, nor > current limited, nor is there any shut-off timer. It is nothing but a > big transformer and rectifier. I had a 1980 C-car. Its charger was pretty crude, but it was a little m

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-31 Thread Lee Hart via EV
One place where Lithium may work better over Lead is for instant/auto start/stop applications. Ben Goren via EV wrote: I would think that such systems will have a relatively short life in the design studios. If you've got an hybrid of any flavor, the electric traction motor is going to be far m

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-31 Thread Lee Hart via EV
Chinese LiFePO4 goes pretty cheap, but that's not the end of it. He'd also need at least a BMS, and probably a new charger. (With some electronics background, he might be able to hack up a way for the BMS to control the C- car charger.) David Nelson via EV wrote: I don't understand why so man

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-31 Thread David Nelson via EV
On Fri, May 29, 2015 at 7:17 PM, EVDL Administrator via EV wrote: > > I wouldn't suggest lithium for him, but not because it's overkill for the > car - more because it might be overkill for him. How can a maintenance free battery that doesn't cause corrosion be overkill for him? > > Chinese LiFe

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-31 Thread Ben Goren via EV
On May 31, 2015, at 1:17 PM, Jay Summet via EV wrote: > One place where Lithium may work better over Lead is for instant/auto > start/stop applications. I would think that such systems will have a relatively short life in the design studios. If you've got an hybrid of any flavor, the electric t

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-31 Thread Ben Goren via EV
On May 31, 2015, at 9:18 AM, Lee Hart wrote: > I don't say this with pride; I'm actually sad to see it work out this way. > It's just that our society creates an overwhelming pressure to keep doing the > Same Old Thing, no matter what, no matter how many better ideas come along, > until absolu

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-31 Thread Jay Summet via EV
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 > But the truth is that lead SLI batteries are good enough for the > job, and they are CHEAP... cheap wins every time. > One place where Lithium may work better over Lead is for instant/auto start/stop applications. (where the starter is much lar

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-31 Thread Lee Hart via EV
EVDL Administrator via EV wrote: You may see lithium SLI batteries in very high end ICEVs. At least one luxury car manufacturer (BMW?) is already using them. Yes; it becomes a marketing "feature", used to sell cars even if there's no advantage. The more features, the better, even if the buyer

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-31 Thread EVDL Administrator via EV
On 31 May 2015 at 11:18, Lee Hart via EV wrote: > our society creates an overwhelming pressure to keep doing the Same Old > Thing, no matter what, no matter how many better ideas come along, > until absolutely FORCED to change You may see lithium SLI batteries in very high end ICEVs. At least o

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-31 Thread Lee Hart via EV
Ben Goren via EV wrote: In general, we are rapidly approaching but not quite yet at the time when lithium trumps lead for all use cases. Once Tesla's Gigafactory comes online, we may well reach that point. It won't be all that long before starter batteries in ICE vehicles are lithium It'

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-30 Thread Cruisin via EV
Don't waste you money on LifePo (Chinese), go with what all the big guys use like the Volt or Leaf batteries. -- View this message in context: http://electric-vehicle-discussion-list.413529.n4.nabble.com/GC-batteries-tp4675848p4675875.html Sent from the Electric Vehicle Discussion List mailing

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-30 Thread Jay Summet via EV
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 I had Sams Club batteries in my S10 EV (20 of them) for my first pack. They were Energizer EGC2 batteries. (The cost was around $1700 5-6 years ago.) They lasted 2 years with good service, and I eked out another 3/4 of a year with reduced range/capac

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-30 Thread Ben Goren via EV
On May 29, 2015, at 5:28 PM, Willie2 via EV wrote: > I believe lithium is now about twice the price of lead for similar energy > storage capacity. In general, we are rapidly approaching but not quite yet at the time when lithium trumps lead for all use cases. Once Tesla's Gigafactory comes onl

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-30 Thread Willie2 via EV
On 05/29/2015 08:22 PM, Lee Hart via EV wrote: Willie: C-cars are only 48v systems, and draw over 500 amps on a routine basis from their batteries. Most cheap lithiums would not like this kind of current at all. I had guessed that 250a would be enough since I rarely see 100a on my 36v golf c

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-29 Thread Michael Ross via EV
It hasn't been stated clearly the Li cells have greater functional capacity for equal total capacity compared to lead acid. You can fill the lead acids to the brim and they on't be hurt, but I understand many people never take them below 50% capacity before recharging - to get as many cycles as po

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-29 Thread EVDL Administrator via EV
On 29 May 2015 at 16:56, Gail Lucas via EV wrote: > One of our local EV gurus suggested money could be saved by using some > from Sam's Club where they can be purchased for under $90.00. As far as quality and longevity, it's a crapshoot. Sam's Club and similar private-brand retail outlets buy

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries vs lithium

2015-05-29 Thread jerry freedomev via EV
ie2 via EV To: Electric Vehicle Discussion List Sent: Friday, May 29, 2015 8:28 PM Subject: Re: [EVDL] GC batteries On 05/29/2015 06:56 PM, Gail Lucas via EV wrote: > where they can be purchased for under $90.00.  Please offer opinions, > but not to upgrade to lithium.  That would be

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-29 Thread Lee Hart via EV
Gail Lucas via EV wrote: Now trying to help select batteries for the ComutaCar. I used Trojan T105s when I had it and the new owner is looking for the same since they are still in it but need to be replaced. One of our local EV gurus suggested money could be saved by using some from Sam's Club wh

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-29 Thread Gail Lucas via EV
know lithium might be an option. Thanks for explaining why this could work without as much expense as I expected. Gail - Original Message - From: "Willie2 via EV" To: "Electric Vehicle Discussion List" Sent: Friday, May 29, 2015 5:28 PM Subject: Re: [EVDL] GC batt

Re: [EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-29 Thread Willie2 via EV
On 05/29/2015 06:56 PM, Gail Lucas via EV wrote: where they can be purchased for under $90.00. Please offer opinions, but not to upgrade to lithium. That would be overkill for a C-Car. I Well... I believe lithium is now about twice the price of lead for similar energy storage capacity.

[EVDL] GC batteries

2015-05-29 Thread Gail Lucas via EV
Hi again, Now trying to help select batteries for the ComutaCar. I used Trojan T105s when I had it and the new owner is looking for the same since they are still in it but need to be replaced. One of our local EV gurus suggested money could be saved by using some from Sam's Club where they c