Re: problem of size '10

2010-03-04 Thread Stathis Papaioannou
On 5 March 2010 06:43, Jack Mallah wrote: >> similarly in your paper where you consider a gradual removal of brain >> tissue. It would have to be very specific surgery to produce the sort of >> delusional state you describe. > > I'm not sure if you overlooked it but the key condition in my pape

Re: problem of size '10

2010-03-04 Thread Jack Mallah
Bruno, I hope you feel better. My quarrel with you is nothing personal. --- Bruno Marchal wrote: > Jack Mallah wrote: > > Bruno, you don't have to assume any 'prescience'; you just have to assume > > that counterfactuals count.  No one but you considers that 'prescience' or > > any kind of pro

Re: problem of size '10

2010-03-04 Thread Jack Mallah
--- On Wed, 3/3/10, Stathis Papaioannou wrote: > Jack Mallah wrote: > > For partial replacement scenarios, where part of a brain has > > counterfactuals and the rest doesn't, see my partial brain paper: > > http://cogprints.org/6321/ > > I've finally come around to reading this paper. You may