Re: [Finale] [OT] clef for high basses

2010-02-23 Thread Christopher Smith
On Tue Feb 23, at TuesdayFeb 23 4:51 PM, Andrew Stiller wrote: Contrabassists don't like the tenor clef, many don't think it's ever appropriate for their instrument, and some can't even read it. That said, you should feel free to write it when needed Bwahaha! Andrew, that's priceless! I

Re: [Finale] [OT] clef for high basses

2010-02-23 Thread Chuck Israels
On Feb 23, 2010, at 1:51 PM, Andrew Stiller wrote: Contrabassists don't like the tenor clef, many don't think it's ever appropriate for their instrument, and some can't even read it. I agree with this - and there's some logic in the habit/convention. Because the cello is tuned in 5ths,

Re: [Finale] [OT] clef for high basses

2010-02-23 Thread Andrew Stiller
Contrabassists don't like the tenor clef, many don't think it's ever appropriate for their instrument, and some can't even read it. That said, you should feel free to write it when needed, but it should be used *more* cautiously on the cb than on the vc--not less, as you guessed. You'll act

Re: [Finale] [OT] clef for high basses

2010-02-21 Thread SN jef chippewa
Basses in tenor clef should still be notated an octave above absolute pitch, so it shouldn't be higher than cellos. (And I assume that you meant to write "how many ledger lines are too much in BASS ...") ah, no i meant tenor *clef*. yes the question is ledger lines, i know about transpos

Re: [Finale] [OT] clef for high basses

2010-02-21 Thread John Howell
At 5:40 AM +0100 2/22/10, SN jef chippewa wrote: how many ledger lines are too much in tenor that warrant a change to tenor clef? D5 (written) seems feasible with only 3 ledger lines, then E5 above the 3rd ledger line should be fine... in all cello literature the change happens (at the latest)

[Finale] [OT] clef for high basses

2010-02-21 Thread SN jef chippewa
how many ledger lines are too much in tenor that warrant a change to tenor clef? D5 (written) seems feasible with only 3 ledger lines, then E5 above the 3rd ledger line should be fine... in all cello literature the change happens (at the latest) as soon as a single C5 is part of the passage,