Re: [Finale] errors in instrument.txt and ensembles.txt now OT trombones

2007-06-08 Thread Raymond Horton
Andrew Stiller wrote: Thank you, Ray for straightening this out so accurately. I had thrown up my hands at any attempt to clear the air on this one, but you have done so admirably. My one quibble: Before valves, in Germany a low F trombone was a "bass trombone" and was similar bore size to to

Re: [Finale] errors in instrument.txt and ensembles.txt now OT trombones

2007-06-07 Thread Andrew Stiller
Thank you, Ray for straightening this out so accurately. I had thrown up my hands at any attempt to clear the air on this one, but you have done so admirably. My one quibble: Before valves, in Germany a low F trombone was a "bass trombone" and was similar bore size to today's large bore tenor.

Re: [Finale] errors in instrument.txt and ensembles.txt now OT trombones

2007-06-07 Thread Raymond Horton
The naming of the F as a "contrabass" trombone has to do with in what role it is meant to function, not just the key. Before valves, in Germany a low F trombone was a "bass trombone" and was similar bore size to today's large bore tenor. It was a rare instrument, much more common was a Bb "