[FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-04 Thread Bryan Bickford
Greetings I am a security researcher who is working on a project in my free time, without going into details - the project will end with a powerful tool being publicly released. Obviously most cyber security tools have the potential for abuse. What sort of legal hurdles (if any) do you need to ov

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-04 Thread Brandon Perry
If I recall correctly, version 1 of metasploit actually had exploits for *live* sites (a bank) and things, so that is obviously an issue. I don't even think you will find a copy of the first version of metasploit (does HD have one locked up somewhere, who knows). Currently, metasploit is a hammer.

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-04 Thread Andres Riancho
Hi. As w3af's project leader I've not received any legal threats over the seven years this project has been alive. Only a couple of months ago, and just to be sure, I added this disclaimer which users need to accept to run the tool. DISCLAIMER = """Usage of w3af for sending any traffic to a targe

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-04 Thread Andres Riancho
Software is SO different to a gun... you can't really compare them. Real people will die in most cases when a gun is misused, only electrons are disturbed (in the great majority of cases) if you misuse a hacking tool. On Fri, Apr 4, 2014 at 3:50 PM, Not EcksKaySeeDee wrote: > Re: Use of a disclai

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-04 Thread Ryan Dewhurst
I believe Germany passed a law about exploits and/or "security tools". Also in the UK, some of the amendments to the CMA has a statement about distributing "articles" which some believe also includes software. I don't know of any case in the UK though where someone has gotten into trouble with this

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-04 Thread Sullo
After a dozen-ish years of Nikto and some other tools, it's not been a problem for me either. However, it doesn't have to be illegal for someone to sue you, or include you in a court case, which can ruin your day and possibly cost you money regardless of right or wrong. Having disclaimers and a l

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-04 Thread Not EcksKaySeeDee
True, s/ware is different from a gun. I mostly meant it tongue in cheek. But I can't help but wonder, what with the increase of people learning to code (mind you, there's a diff between hobby and serious, I accept that), and the whole Internet of Things, and the fact that most modern hardware (nucl

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-04 Thread Brunner, Mark
://www.brookfield.com/emaildisclaimer. -Original Message- From: Fulldisclosure [mailto:fulldisclosure-boun...@seclists.org] On Behalf Of Andres Riancho Sent: Friday, April 04, 2014 2:57 PM To: Not EcksKaySeeDee Cc: fulldisclosure@seclists.org Subject: Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-04 Thread Volker Tanger
Greetings! > I believe Germany passed a law about exploits and/or "security > tools".[...] I *believe* it is taken pretty seriously in > Germany though. Of course it's taken seriously here in Germany. We take EVERYTHING seriously. ;-) The law (§202c StGB) and its application already have b

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-05 Thread Toni Korpela
Greetings from Finland. I know that here it is illegal to import, manufacture, sell or otherwise distribute such machine or software which are designed to endanger or harm information and communication systems. This is stated in chapter 34 § 9a. Then again § 9b states that it is illegal to poses

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-05 Thread Toni Korpela
Sorry. For the last message and that I forgot to include where the chapter 34 sections 9a and 9b can be found.. They are on the following translated document of the Finnish Criminal Code: http://www.finlex.fi/fi/laki/kaannokset/1889/en18890039.pdf You can find sections 9a and 9b on pages 143 a

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-05 Thread John Young
osure-boun...@seclists.org] On Behalf Of Andres Riancho Sent: Friday, April 04, 2014 2:57 PM To: Not EcksKaySeeDee Cc: fulldisclosure@seclists.org Subject: Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools Software is SO different to a gun... you can't really compare them. Real people will die in most cases when a

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-06 Thread Henri Salo
On Sat, Apr 05, 2014 at 01:23:51PM +0300, Toni Korpela wrote: > Greetings from Finland. > > I know that here it is illegal to import, manufacture, sell > or otherwise distribute such machine or software which > are designed to endanger or harm information and > communication systems. Basic examp

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-06 Thread coderman
On Fri, Apr 4, 2014 at 3:29 PM, John Young wrote: > Would you suggest it is time to license security professionals like > architects, engineers, doctors and others lawfully empowered to > police hazardous systems in the public interest? the industry itself is the problem; no more security differe

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-06 Thread Jeffrey Walton
On Sun, Apr 6, 2014 at 4:24 AM, Henri Salo wrote: > On Sat, Apr 05, 2014 at 01:23:51PM +0300, Toni Korpela wrote: >> Greetings from Finland. >> >> I know that here it is illegal to import, manufacture, sell >> or otherwise distribute such machine or software which >> are designed to endanger or ha

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-06 Thread coderman
On Fri, Apr 4, 2014 at 3:58 AM, Bryan Bickford wrote: > ... > I am a security researcher who is working on a project in my free time, > without going into details - the project will end with a powerful tool > being publicly released. yes, but released under what license? :) > Obviously most cy

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-06 Thread Toni Korpela
Hey Salo. I know that the act of port scanning without permission is illegal even though easily done thanks to Fyodor's nmap. The thing is that I find it really funny that I can not distribute nmap legally to a friend at some other point of the Internet and ask him to port scan my IP address. T

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-06 Thread Toni Korpela
On 04/06/2014 11:54 AM, Jeffrey Walton wrote: On Sun, Apr 6, 2014 at 4:24 AM, Henri Salo wrote: Basic examples, which I have personally encountered: 1) Not allowed to port scan. Some ISPs are already monitoring and warning users in case they do port scanning, but the reason for alerting might

Re: [FD] Legality of Open Source Tools

2014-04-07 Thread Daniel Wood
Toni, The English version has this information in Chapter 38, I didn't find it in a Chapter 34. The key to all this is the language of intent, using verbiage such as "aggravated", "unlawful", and "to cause detriment". This is the same as the United States and many other countries; if you don'