[fw-general] Re: Stuck in loop with Zend_Controller_Action::_forward() and Zend_Controller_Plugin_Abstract::preDispatch()

2007-03-30 Thread Nick Lo
Hi Simon, I've sussed out where the issue is and have commented it in the following: The example url; site.com/auth/ goes to default/controllers/ AuthController.php... AuthController extends Zend_Controller_Action { public function indexAction() { $this-_forward( 'login',

[fw-general] Re: Stuck in loop with Zend_Controller_Action::_forward() and Zend_Controller_Plugin_Abstract::preDispatch()

2007-03-29 Thread Simon Mundy
What happens if you add:- $this-add(new Zend_Acl_Resource('default')); $this-allow(null, 'login'); Hey, no worries. I'm here and I'm finding any excuse to get distracted at the moment :) I had read your code too quickly - yes indeed, you're using a plugin. It looks to me that you're

[fw-general] Re: Stuck in loop with Zend_Controller_Action::_forward() and Zend_Controller_Plugin_Abstract::preDispatch()

2007-03-29 Thread Nick Lo
What happens if you add:- $this-add(new Zend_Acl_Resource('default')); $this-allow(null, 'login'); Well the default resource is already there so just adding the latter bit results in: Fatal error: Uncaught exception 'Zend_Acl_Exception' with message 'Resource 'login' not found' in...

[fw-general] Re: Stuck in loop with Zend_Controller_Action::_forward() and Zend_Controller_Plugin_Abstract::preDispatch()

2007-03-29 Thread Nick Lo
Forgot to finish that by asking if you are able to get _forward() doing its stuff succesfully, presuming of course, a similar Controller plugin, Auth, Acl, etc setup as you originally specified (and I pinched)? If not then I'll know it's not just me. Thanks, Nick What happens if you

[fw-general] Re: Stuck in loop with Zend_Controller_Action::_forward() and Zend_Controller_Plugin_Abstract::preDispatch()

2007-03-29 Thread Nick Lo
A further follow up: The secret recipe seems to be to use dispatchLoopStartup() rather than preDispatch as in: class Menu_Controller_Plugin_Auth extends Zend_Controller_Plugin_Abstract { private $_auth; private $_acl; private $_noauth = array('module' = 'default',

[fw-general] Re: Stuck in loop with Zend_Controller_Action::_forward() and Zend_Controller_Plugin_Abstract::preDispatch()

2007-03-29 Thread Simon Mundy
Hi Nick So you're saying that if you set the request's action via setActionName(), it will trigger another forward? Even if it's the same value as it was before the plugin performed its check? Must have been one of those subtle changes from 0.7 - 0.9 that I missed. Thanks for spotting

[fw-general] Re: Stuck in loop with Zend_Controller_Action::_forward() and Zend_Controller_Plugin_Abstract::preDispatch()

2007-03-28 Thread Simon Mundy
Hi Nick No mystery there - having the auth logic embedded within the Controller means preDispatch will be called each time the controller is called... sending it onto the same controller... with the same preDispatch... etc... I'd recommend either:- a) Moving the preDispatch controller

[fw-general] Re: Stuck in loop with Zend_Controller_Action::_forward() and Zend_Controller_Plugin_Abstract::preDispatch()

2007-03-28 Thread Nick Lo
Hi Simon, Thanks for the super quick reply, I didn't mean to summons you to an answer by the way, I just cc'd past you since I was using your code and thought you might be interested. I don't quite follow but, suspecting I may be being dense here, I'll go ahead anyway... No mystery

[fw-general] Re: Stuck in loop with Zend_Controller_Action::_forward() and Zend_Controller_Plugin_Abstract::preDispatch()

2007-03-28 Thread Simon Mundy
Hey, no worries. I'm here and I'm finding any excuse to get distracted at the moment :) I had read your code too quickly - yes indeed, you're using a plugin. It looks to me that you're requesting a controller name that the ACL is returning as a DENY. And then you're _forward'ing to another