Re: gEDA-user: PCB: Rotate in steps of 30 and 45 degree?

2006-10-03 Thread Dan McMahill
Florian Steiper wrote: DJ Delorie wrote: Has anyone thought about doing a footprint rotating utility? The problem isn't rotating the footprint, it's that nothing in pcb expects pads to be other than orthogonal. For example, the gerber exporter can't plot angled lines with square

Re: gEDA-user: PCB: Rotate in steps of 30 and 45 degree?

2006-10-03 Thread Dan McMahill
DJ Delorie wrote: Has anyone thought about doing a footprint rotating utility? The problem isn't rotating the footprint, it's that nothing in pcb expects pads to be other than orthogonal. For example, the gerber exporter can't plot angled lines with square corners, it would have to draw them

Re: gEDA-user: Newbie PCB DRC questions

2006-10-03 Thread joeft
Peter, I don't believe these small segments are due to the autoroute process. I see them a lot and I've never used the auto-router. I believe they can occur when: You add a line containing several segments with snap to pins and pads turned on. This can put a short ( 1 grid long) segment

gEDA-user: Re: Design changs required to mill PCBs?

2006-10-03 Thread Matthew Sager
Hello all, I know when I was using an LPKF machine at school I had to watch the clearance between vias. The LPKF software we had made two passes around the vias for extra clearances I assume this was to make it easier to solder. We made 2 layer boards for our class project. For connecting layers

gEDA-user: home-made 4 layer board idea

2006-10-03 Thread DJ Delorie
The biggest problem with home-made boards is the vias, right? What if you drilled the outer panels with larger holes, so that you could solder to the inner layers? You wouldn't even need copper on the unused outer layer, you could just drill it out. \\ --==

Re: gEDA-user: home-made 4 layer board idea

2006-10-03 Thread Harry Eaton
DJ Delorie wrote: Plus the usual problem of obtaining the thin outer clads, and precise enough drilling. Don't forget the chemicals, tanks, protective gloves, resist, photomask (or equivalent). ___ geda-user mailing list

Re: gEDA-user: home-made 4 layer board idea

2006-10-03 Thread DJ Delorie
Don't forget the chemicals, tanks, protective gloves, resist, photomask (or equivalent). I'm all set on that. I did the two prototypes for the smd challenge myself, for example, that's 6 mil rules. But I haven't seen any 0.016 single clad in small quantities yet. Not that I've been looking

Re: gEDA-user: Newbie PCB DRC questions

2006-10-03 Thread Dave McGuire
On Oct 3, 2006, at 8:32 PM, John Griessen wrote: I think the way some of these come into being is faster-than-the- eye-can-see action sorta-like contact bounce, but it's mouse- contact-bounce. Sounds like a deviant kind of ball game. But really, who knows? ?quien sabe? como estan mouse

Re: gEDA-user: Re: Design changs required to mill PCBs?

2006-10-03 Thread Bob Paddock
On Tuesday 03 October 2006 19:05, DJ Delorie wrote: No fair, now I'm jealous. I want expensive toys too! ;-) One of the companies I do consulting for bought that machine. I think their long term plan is to do prototype boards for people in the Pittsburgh area. Right now they are just doing

Re: gEDA-user: Re: Design changs required to mill PCBs?

2006-10-03 Thread DJ Delorie
I always wanted one myself. How that I've actually used it, I think the funds could have been better used on test equipment. Yeah, I'm just drooling. I'm a tool junkie. It makes $33, http://www.33each.com , for a single two layer board look cheap when you consider all of the time you

Re: gEDA-user: home-made 4 layer board idea

2006-10-03 Thread gene glick
how about layer registration? If the tolerances are out of whack, nothing will line up very well. DJ Delorie wrote: Don't forget the chemicals, tanks, protective gloves, resist, photomask (or equivalent). I'm all set on that. I did the two prototypes for the smd challenge myself, for

Re: gEDA-user: home-made 4 layer board idea

2006-10-03 Thread DJ Delorie
how about layer registration? If the tolerances are out of whack, nothing will line up very well. I think if the individual layers are accurate (or at least equally distorted), lining up the drilled clad shouldn't be a problem - just add two corner holes, drill them separately on each board,

Re: gEDA-user: home-made 4 layer board idea

2006-10-03 Thread John Griessen
DJ Delorie wrote: The biggest problem with home-made boards is the vias, right? What if you drilled the outer panels with larger holes, so that you could solder to the inner layers? Sounds reasonable when you allow for extra area, which is also reasonable for a start on a product with

Re: gEDA-user: home-made 4 layer board idea

2006-10-03 Thread gene glick
my favorite layout guy once explained the notion of datum lines (I think that's what they are called). Anyway, if you use an arbitrary line (datum) in the center of your board, and reference all measurements to it, the tolerances are only from that imaginary 1/2 way point to the edges. It's

Re: gEDA-user: home-made 4 layer board idea

2006-10-03 Thread DJ Delorie
Sounds reasonable when you allow for extra area, which is also reasonable for a start on a product with low volume, and afford a re-layout later. Right. In the photos, the pads that are relevent are larger. You wouldn't even need copper on the unused outer layer, you could just drill it

Re: gEDA-user: home-made 4 layer board idea

2006-10-03 Thread DJ Delorie
my favorite layout guy once explained the notion of datum lines (I think that's what they are called). Anyway, if you use an arbitrary line (datum) in the center of your board, and reference all measurements to it, the tolerances are only from that imaginary 1/2 way point to the edges.

Re: gEDA-user: Re: Design changs required to mill PCBs?

2006-10-03 Thread John Griessen
Since engineering is just the balancing of cost and performance, another way to look at this problem is to see that many many power supplies can be made with one layer plus ground plane boards -- 2 layer, and RF boards need 4 or six layers, and the rest need one layer, and slant your design

Re: gEDA-user: home-made 4 layer board idea

2006-10-03 Thread Harry Eaton
DJ Delorie wrote: Don't forget the chemicals, tanks, protective gloves, resist, photomask (or equivalent). I'm all set on that. I did the two prototypes for the smd challenge myself, for example, that's 6 mil rules. How do you put on your LPI soldermask? Do you use an old turntable

Re: gEDA-user: Re: Design changs required to mill PCBs?

2006-10-03 Thread DJ Delorie
and slant your design choices towards one layer. In my case, I have a specific space to fill, and it's in a high noise environment. I need the power planes to avoid noise issues. But yeah, fitting a design into less layers (like my current RAM board, which has flood-filled power polys on both

Re: gEDA-user: Re: Design changs required to mill PCBs?

2006-10-03 Thread David Carr
How did you get that pcbpool quote? I just got one for a 4 layer 50x50mm prototype and it was 143 euro which is way more than $104. I'd love to get 4 layers for $100! -DC DJ Delorie wrote: I always wanted one myself. How that I've actually used it, I think the funds could have been better