Re: commons-compress - Gump/Maven issues?

2004-06-22 Thread Stefan Bodewig
On Mon, 21 Jun 2004, Eric Pugh <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I don't know what extent you want to push back on the projects that > gump builds, but it seems to me that they are either doing something > that pushes maven beyond it's limits, Quite possible. Or maybe not. AFAIU we are successfully

Re: commons-compress - Gump/Maven issues?

2004-06-22 Thread Stefan Bodewig
On Mon, 21 Jun 2004, Niclas Hedhman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On Monday 21 June 2004 22:47, Stefan Bodewig wrote: > >> (1) The descriptor of commons-compress sets a property named >> component.version and hopes to get this into the jar name, which >> obviously doesn't work that way. Maven stil

Re: commons-compress - Gump/Maven issues?

2004-06-22 Thread Stefan Bodewig
On Mon, 21 Jun 2004, Stephen McConnell <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > To do real integration you need to be able do to something like set > some special property so that magic or maven can take control over > classloader definition in the knowledge that the build is a gump > build This is what buil

Re: commons-compress - Gump/Maven issues?

2004-06-21 Thread Adam R. B. Jack
> My conclusion is that the maven scenario is very similar to the magic > scenario. To do real integration you need to be able do to something > like set some special property so that magic or maven can take control > over classloader definition in the knowledge that the build is a gump > build (i

Re: commons-compress - Gump/Maven issues?

2004-06-21 Thread Adam R. B. Jack
> The question is, does Maven fully support disabling the normal 'repository > management' allowing Gump to provide the artifacts for each project? Theoretically yes, but I think Stefan has disproved that it isn't leak-proof. > Can Maven be told to ignore versions in the POMs ? Yes. > I have s

Re: commons-compress - Gump/Maven issues?

2004-06-21 Thread Niclas Hedhman
On Tuesday 22 June 2004 00:32, Eric Pugh wrote: > I don't know what extent you want to push back on the projects that gump > builds, but it seems to me that they are either doing something that pushes > maven beyond it's limits, or the decriptor might be out of date. > > I checked out jakarta-commo

Re: commons-compress - Gump/Maven issues?

2004-06-21 Thread Stephen McConnell
Stefan Bodewig wrote: Hi all, two notes colored by my complete lack of Maven knowledge: (1) The descriptor of commons-compress sets a property named component.version and hopes to get this into the jar name, which obviously doesn't work that way. Maven still uses /project/currentVersion from the P

Re: commons-compress - Gump/Maven issues?

2004-06-21 Thread Mario Ivankovits
Eric Pugh wrote: I checked out jakarta-commons-sandbox/compress to investigate furthur, but I don't see this descriptor property you are talking about.. Could you enlightenme on this? If you mean the gump.xml - i only added fragments of it into gump/project/jakarta-commons-sandbox.xml in the g

RE: commons-compress - Gump/Maven issues?

2004-06-21 Thread Eric Pugh
ut I don't see this descriptor property you are talking about.. Could you enlightenme on this? Eric > -Original Message- > From: Niclas Hedhman [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: Monday, June 21, 2004 5:30 PM > To: Gump code and data > Subject: Re: commons-compress

Re: commons-compress - Gump/Maven issues?

2004-06-21 Thread Adam R. B. Jack
> > For things like directories for compiled classes this probably > > is good, but it may also lead to situations where Gump doesn't manage > > to substitute a jar from CVS with a freshly compiled one. > > Generally, Maven will happily download the required Jars from remote > repositories, which

Re: commons-compress - Gump/Maven issues?

2004-06-21 Thread Niclas Hedhman
On Monday 21 June 2004 22:47, Stefan Bodewig wrote: > (1) The descriptor of commons-compress sets a property named > component.version and hopes to get this into the jar name, which > obviously doesn't work that way. Maven still uses > /project/currentVersion from the POM. If no Maven guys are a

commons-compress - Gump/Maven issues?

2004-06-21 Thread Stefan Bodewig
Hi all, two notes colored by my complete lack of Maven knowledge: (1) The descriptor of commons-compress sets a property named component.version and hopes to get this into the jar name, which obviously doesn't work that way. Maven still uses /project/currentVersion from the POM. I've adapted th