Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-15 Thread Kanak Biscuitwala
that are already existing vehicles for achieving the aims discussed in the Slider proposal. Twill: handles all the AM logic for running new code packaged as a JAR with an executor method Bigtop: stack testing As a Bigtop committer, I disagree with this narrow interpretation of the scope of the project

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-14 Thread Steve Loughran
for achieving the aims discussed in the Slider proposal. Twill: handles all the AM logic for running new code packaged as a JAR with an executor method Bigtop: stack testing As a Bigtop committer, I disagree with this narrow interpretation of the scope of the project

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-14 Thread Steve Loughran
On 14 April 2014 04:43, Andreas Neumann a...@apache.org wrote: I'd like to comment on what has been said about Twill. Twill: handles all the AM logic for running new code packaged as a JAR with an executor method The goal of Twill is much broader than to support writing new code. Its

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-13 Thread Andreas Neumann
wrote: The reason I ask is I'm wondering how Slider differentiates from projects like Apache Twill or Apache Bigtop that are already existing vehicles for achieving the aims discussed in the Slider proposal. Twill: handles all the AM logic for running new code packaged as a JAR

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-12 Thread Steve Loughran
works- so assistance would be welcome. The reason I ask is I'm wondering how Slider differentiates from projects like Apache Twill or Apache Bigtop that are already existing vehicles for achieving the aims discussed in the Slider proposal. Twill: handles all the AM logic for running new code

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-12 Thread Andrew Purtell
differentiates from projects like Apache Twill or Apache Bigtop that are already existing vehicles for achieving the aims discussed in the Slider proposal. Twill: handles all the AM logic for running new code packaged as a JAR with an executor method Bigtop: stack testing As a Bigtop committer, I

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-12 Thread Roman Shaposhnik
On Sat, Apr 12, 2014 at 11:58 AM, Andrew Purtell apurt...@apache.org wrote: The reason I ask is I'm wondering how Slider differentiates from projects like Apache Twill or Apache Bigtop that are already existing vehicles for achieving the aims discussed in the Slider proposal. Twill

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-10 Thread Andrew Purtell
Apache Twill or Apache Bigtop that are already existing vehicles for achieving the aims discussed in the Slider proposal. Tackling cross-component resource management issues could certainly be that, but only if core Hadoop services are also brought into the deployment and management model, because IO

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-02 Thread Arun C. Murthy
Looks great, thanks for the update Steve. Arun On Mar 31, 2014, at 8:49 PM, Steve Loughran ste...@hortonworks.com wrote: Hi For people wondering what's been happening with that Hoya proposal, I've got a successor proposal up for discussion.

Slider Proposal

2014-03-31 Thread Steve Loughran
Hi For people wondering what's been happening with that Hoya proposal, I've got a successor proposal up for discussion. https://wiki.apache.org/incubator/SliderProposal This proposal -as well as having a different name- is a superset of the original draft. It emphasises that making the tool