Avalon, Commons, once again (Re: Commons Validator Packaging/Content)

2002-01-08 Thread Jeff Turner
On Tue, Jan 08, 2002 at 09:29:18PM +1100, Peter Donald wrote: ... > > To drive this point home, the subject line of this thread identifies > > exactly one such set of duplication - between Turbine and Struts. My > > nagging lead Berin to propose moving the Avalon collections code into > > commons

Re: Avalon, Commons, once again (Re: Commons Validator Packaging/Content)

2002-01-08 Thread Sam Ruby
Paul Hammont wrote: > > There is some romance to extending the 'honor system' to the whole of > Jakarta. When we became committers we all treaded tentatively until > we'd fully earned the respect of the seasoned veterans in the project in > question. An 'open' Jakarta would be nice, but even wit

Re: Avalon, Commons, once again (Re: Commons Validator Packaging/Content)

2002-01-08 Thread Paul Hammant
Sam, >I have quietly stated several times that I would prefer that a Jakarta >committer is a Jakarta committer. Gaging by the response I got each time, >I figured that then was not the time to push the issue. > There is some romance to extending the 'honor system' to the whole of Jakarta. Whe

Re: Avalon, Commons, once again (Re: Commons Validator Packaging/Content)

2002-01-08 Thread Sam Ruby
Ted Husted wrote: > > As it stands, both are simply subprojects, and so a Commons committer is > a Commons committer. Ditto for Taglibs. It is also fair to point out that an Avalon committer is a committer to the framework itself as well as to testlet, logkit, phoenix, cornerstone, excalibur, and

Re: Avalon, Commons, once again (Re: Commons Validator Packaging/Content)

2002-01-08 Thread Ted Husted
Jeff Turner wrote: > Has that turned out to be a problem in practice? Say if you think so, > and we can propose a modification to the charter: "The votes of those > who haven't committed to a project are non-binding". That would be a matter to be discussed on the Commons (and/or Tablibs) lists.,

Avalon, Commons, once again (Re: Commons Validator Packaging/Content)

2002-01-08 Thread Jeff Turner
On Tue, Jan 08, 2002 at 09:29:18PM +1100, Peter Donald wrote: ... > > To drive this point home, the subject line of this thread identifies > > exactly one such set of duplication - between Turbine and Struts. My > > nagging lead Berin to propose moving the Avalon collections code into > > commons