Re: [geo] Carbon budget/removal in NYTimes interactive

2017-09-15 Thread Ken Caldeira
Folks, To point out the obvious, the results of Kwaitkowski et al may or may not scale to smaller deployments, and the effects of smaller deployments are likely to be regionally dependent. I have been wanting to look at combined climate / energy implications of widespread deployment of OTEC facil

Re: [geo] Carbon budget/removal in NYTimes interactive

2017-09-15 Thread Stephen Salter
Hi All A problem with pumping cold water up to the surface is that it will sink quite fast. Kaye and Laby give the density of 3.5% salinity water at 5 C as 1027.68 and at 25 C as 1023.34 kg/m3 We can work out the drag on various shapes of object and find the velocity which gives a drag for

[geo] CDR recommended to avoid catastrophic climate change

2017-09-15 Thread Eric Durbrow
A new PNAS article on ways to mitigate catastrophic climate scenario. They try to gauge probabilities for catastrophic/extreme and “unknown/extreme scenarios. They include carbon extraction and sequestration (but I think they mean ambient CDR rather than carbon extraction from fossil fuel power pl

Re: [geo] Carbon budget/removal in NYTimes interactive

2017-09-15 Thread William H. Calvin
Re cold water pumped up then sinking: Might this help solve the problem of sinking organic carbon before it decomposes? William H. Calvin wcal...@uw.edu From: geoengineering@googlegroups.com on behalf of Stephen Salter Sent: Friday, September 15, 2017 9:18:30 A

RE: [geo] SOS 2017 Session spotlight 4 - Ocean NETs - CO2 Sequestration Via Ocean-Based Negative Emissions Technologies

2017-09-15 Thread Peter Flynn
This prompts several comments, and apologies for the delay and to those for whom this is too basic: 1. The ocean can be thought of as two relatively independent bodies of water, the shallow and deep ocean. There is a fairly sharp boundary between the two, called the thermocline. Transfer between

RE: [geo] SOS 2017 Session spotlight 4 - Ocean NETs - CO2 Sequestration Via Ocean-Based Negative Emissions Technologies

2017-09-15 Thread Andrew Lockley
Thanks Peter. However, you don't address whether pumping water into sealed tubes or greenhouses would be viable. Deep water isn't that deep - water for my toilet is pumped much further. As long as the water lifted was kept away from the atmosphere and surface ocean, it should be effective at fert

Re: [geo] SOS 2017 Session spotlight 4 - Ocean NETs - CO2 Sequestration Via Ocean-Based Negative Emissions Technologies

2017-09-15 Thread Klaus Lackner
I agree with all of that. The shallow ocean has neither the storage capacity nor the residence time to be a good site for storing CO2. While ocean currents may not make it possible to push CO2 down into the deep ocean, you have technical options. For example, you literally could pump liquid CO

Re: [geo] SOS 2017 Session spotlight 4 - Ocean NETs - CO2 Sequestration Via Ocean-Based Negative Emissions Technologies

2017-09-15 Thread Greg Rau
Couple of points:1) It is possible to move ocean heat to the deep ocean without moving water, nutrients or salt, and to do this in the context of OTEC with higher efficiency and less environmental impact than vertically pumping massive quantities of water: https://patents.google.com/patent/US857

RE: [geo] SOS 2017 Session spotlight 4 - Ocean NETs - CO2 Sequestration Via Ocean-Based Negative Emissions Technologies

2017-09-15 Thread Peter Flynn
I’m having a problem replying to Greg Rau’s e mail, so I’m trying to do this via a response to Klaus’ e mail. One concern about using the deep ocean as a heat sink is the increased volume / reduced density as temperature rises, causing sea level rise. I have done no calculations, so I have no id

RE: [geo] SOS 2017 Session spotlight 4 - Ocean NETs - CO2 Sequestration Via Ocean-Based Negative Emissions Technologies

2017-09-15 Thread Peter Flynn
Andrew, I’m not sure I understand your comment that deep water isn’t that deep. Typical numbers for the shallow ocean are a depth of 200 meter, with a thermocline between 200 and 1000 meters and a very consistent temperature and salinity below 1000 meters. See, for example: https://oceanservi