Mario wrote:
Does Mr. Ribeiro even know that said paragaph was inserted? How do
you know for sure whether he has issued a disclaimer or not, which the
TOI may not have published?
Would you please contact him and let us know whether he disclaims the
paragraph or not?
Date: Wed, 3 Dec 2008
Bosco:As far as being a credible source of news I have little doubt
that the latter is more credible than the former (an online forum).
However it is not clear if JFR authored the column or was interviewed
for the column.
Chronology:
TOI article above is dated Nov 28, 2008 - No time of posting
.Mario :Does Mr. Ribeiro even know that said paragaph was inserted? How do
you know for sure whether he has issued a disclaimer or not, which the TOI
may not have published?Would you please contact him and let us know whether
he disclaims the paragraph or not?
Response: Mario, I am amazed at your
From: Santosh Helekar
It is really sad to see a tribute to a fallen hero being sullied
by such cheap political propaganda, and I doubt a dignified person
like Julio Ribeiro would ever do such a thing.
Please compare the two versions of the article at the following links:
Santosh: One ought to be seriously concerned whether Times of India editors
injected their own partisanship and ideology into Julio Ribeiro's article by
providing a politically sensational title and adding more than a paragraph
infusing electoral politics into his text.
It is really sad to see a
--- On Mon, 12/1/08, Marshall Mendonza [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Till date there has been no disclaimer from Mr Ribeiro that the said
paragraph was not written by him. Do we then conclude that Mr Ribeiro has
injected his own partisanship and ideology into his article by infusing
electoral
Date: Mon, 1 Dec 2008 13:33:12 +0530
From: Marshall Mendonza [EMAIL PROTECTED]
The article appeared in the Times of India on 28.11.2008. Till date there has
been no disclaimer from Mr Ribeiro that the said paragraph was not written by
him.
Mario asks:
Marshall,
As a voice of truth, reason
In the post appended below it is claimed that an article by Julio Ribeiro has
the title: The BJP's slander campaign did not deter Karkare from his dharma.
It is also claimed that it was published in the Times of India. However, the
weblink provided at the end of the post is to a discussion
Santosh: In the post appended below it is claimed that an article by Julio
Ribeiro has the title: The BJP's slander campaign did not deter Karkare
from his dharma. It is also claimed that it was published in the Times of
India. However, the weblink provided at the end of the post is to a
-Original Message-
From: Marshall Mendonza
Of late I notice that for a person claiming to possess scientific
temper, Santosh has developed a habit of rushing to conclusions without
getting his basics right.
Though I do not owe Santosh any explanation, out of courtesy,
RESPONSE:
--- On Sun, 11/30/08, Marshall Mendonza [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Of late I notice that for a person claiming to possess scientific temper,
Santosh has developed a habit of rushing to conclusions without getting his
basics right.
What else is new? Hurl innuendo and cheap shots at the
The BJP's slander campaign did not deter Karkare from his dharma
Julio Ribeiro ( Times of India 28.11.2008)
Hemant Karkare came to meet me on Tuesday. He was shaken by L K Advani's
all e g at i o n s that the antiterrorist squad, which he headed, had acted
in a politically motivated
12 matches
Mail list logo
