Re: [Goanet] Why can't India develop world-class athletes???

2008-09-01 Thread CORNEL DACOSTA
Hi Edward Can I suggest significantly instead of entirely? But surely, Mario meant exactly what he intended in his precise and impeccable English and not what you think he should have said Edward! However, I am not sure we got much of an answer to the above subject line. And now, re a previous

[Goanet] Why can't India develop world-class athletes???

2008-09-01 Thread Venantius Pinto
Hello Mario, There is no question that it is finally and always the individual athlete or team that competes. By entirely, what I imply is that the Chinese left no stone unturned in re-creating and following the earlier Soviet system and showed that it works for a nation to produce medals -

[Goanet] Why can't India develop world-class athletes??

2008-08-31 Thread edward desilva
jane gillian rodrigues said: My eldest son used to play chess and basketball (from school and college)at district, state level etc. You must experience first-hand the horrible facilities for athletes. There are also the sport selectors with their own brand of politics, who want athletes of their

[Goanet] Why can't India develop world-class athletes??

2008-08-30 Thread jane gillian rodrigues
India develop world-class athletes??? To: goanet [EMAIL PROTECTED] Message-ID: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8 ?Mario said: You don't seem to be familiar with India outside Goa, but there are millions of meat-eating Indians in the north, south, east, west and center

Re: [Goanet] Why can't India develop world-class athletes???

2008-08-30 Thread Mario Goveia
Date: Fri, 29 Aug 2008 16:58:30 +0900 From: Venantius Pinto [EMAIL PROTECTED] Chinese victories on the other hand are entirely the effort of a state system. Mario observes: Venantius, you might want to reconsider the word entirely. Regardless of how much assistance the state provides in

[Goanet] Why can't India develop world class athletes

2008-08-29 Thread edward desilva
Mario responds: Thanks for making my point, which is that India is not able to produce world-class athletes, even when those in the military and railways play all day. I still haven't seen a sensible explanation from you as to why a giant intellectual superpower like India cannot produce

Re: [Goanet] Why can't India develop world-class athletes???

2008-08-29 Thread Venantius Pinto
Regarding the unabashed joy of Indians at Bindra's victory we have to note a few points. Some of which I read three days ago in a piece by by Shashi Tharoor the Daily Yomiuri (English ed). Indian victories by and large in any field are largely by sheer individual effort and determination -- the

[Goanet] Why can't India develop world class athletes

2008-08-29 Thread Mario Goveia
Date: Thu, 28 Aug 2008 08:45:32 + (GMT) From: edward desilva [EMAIL PROTECTED] Obviously, you have not heard of the Chinese POLITBURORO vs Indian bribery system. Secondly you do not know the difference of administration between Communism?vs belpuri bribery infused democratic system of India.

[Goanet] Why can't India develop world-class athletes???

2008-08-28 Thread Mario Goveia
Date: Wed, 27 Aug 2008 09:11:20 + (GMT) From: edward desilva [EMAIL PROTECTED] Well! Well! well! I have spent more time outside of Goa than in it. Allahabad, Jabalpur. Bengal, Madhya Preadesh (Indore, Satna etc). Mario asks: In that case you must know that your previous comments were false.

[Goanet] Why can't India develop world-class athletes???

2008-08-27 Thread edward desilva
 Mario said: You don't seem to be familiar with India outside Goa, but there are millions of meat-eating Indians in the north, south, east, west and center as well as in Goa. -- Reply: Well! Well! well! I have spent more time outside of Goa than in it. Allahabad, Jabalpur. Bengal, Madhya

[Goanet] Why can't India develop world-class athletes???

2008-08-26 Thread edward desilva
Why? Because belpuri and pakora diet is not good enough. If any one tries to educate them, they are burnt alive. That's why. ED. Send instant messages to your online friends http://uk.messenger.yahoo.com

[Goanet] Why can't India develop world-class athletes???

2008-08-26 Thread Mario Goveia
Date: Tue, 26 Aug 2008 11:23:15 + (GMT) From: edward desilva [EMAIL PROTECTED] Why? Because belpuri and pakora diet is not good enough. If any one tries to educate them, they are burnt alive. That's why. Mario observes: Edward I'm sorry to inform you that they don't burn anyone alive that

[Goanet] Why can't India develop world-class athletes???

2008-08-25 Thread Mario Goveia
The following essay by Indian humorist Melvin Durai is funny and yet exposes India's chronic inability to develop world class athletes - except in cricket - from among over a billion people, whereas tiny and relatively poor countries like Jamaica, the Bahamas, Trinidad Tobago, Kenya, Cuba, and