Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-10 Thread Tzafrir Cohen
On Sun, Feb 08, 2009 at 07:27:39PM +0200, Eli Billauer wrote: > Dotan Cohen wrote: > > > The hole here is that he is not expected to read the Windows EULA > > until it is explicitly presented to him at first boot. He could _then_ > > decide to reject the license and contact Dell. It also says, > >

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-09 Thread Zvi Devir
Quoting Shachar Shemesh: > Zvi Devir wrote: > > However, I won't start the process with > > you unless you really want to go all the way (up to district court if > > required). > > > It is not at all trivial that, should the small claims court fail, the > district court is an option. If memo

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-09 Thread Shachar Shemesh
Zvi Devir wrote: > However, I won't start the process with > you unless you really want to go all the way (up to district court if > required). > It is not at all trivial that, should the small claims court fail, the district court is an option. If memory serves me correctly, you are not aut

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-09 Thread Shachar Shemesh
Shachar Raindel wrote: > > > When shopping for my laptop (Dell Inspiron 1525) I found out that > windows Vista basic have a NEGATIVE price of 200$ - the N series which > had linux preinstalled cost 200 USD more than the normal variation, > which was (and still is) in a constant "sale", offering it

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-09 Thread Shachar Shemesh
Orr Dunkelman wrote: > > > The only reason Microsoft cannot have the benefit of "Buy us or > else..." is the fact that they control too large portion of the > market. The moment they will go under 70%, they would be able to > actually say the above (70% may be country dependent). > > > There is

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Oron Peled
Eli, I must say I'm surprised... On Sunday, 8 בFebruary 2009, Eli Billauer wrote: > I have to say that the monopoly argument is refreshing. I don't know > about the law in this case, but given that there are stable alternatives > around for basically any of their products, and they are all for f

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Shachar Raindel
On Sun, Feb 8, 2009 at 7:27 PM, Eli Billauer wrote: > As far as I've seen, it tells the user to check the policy for refund. > It can very well be to cancel the whole deal, for a refund of the whole > sum. And the software can also be considered a present. I mean, suppose > that you go to the supe

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Dotan Cohen
> As far as I've seen, it tells the user to check the policy for refund. It > can very well be to cancel the whole deal, for a refund of the whole sum. > And the software can also be considered a present. I mean, suppose that you > go to the supermarket, and you get an extra piece of something beca

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Eli Billauer
Orr Dunkelman wrote:. > The only reason Microsoft cannot have the benefit of "Buy us or > else..." is the fact that they control too large portion of the > market. The moment they will go under 70%, they would be able to > actually say the above (70% may be country dependent). > I have to say t

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Zvi Devir
Hi Dan, There is no law (in Israel) that forbids bundling laptops with Windows. Since almost all laptops come with Windows preinstall, it is pointless to search for white box laptop, as those are usually low-end laptops. You should buy the laptop you want with whatever OS it comes with, and af

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Orr Dunkelman
On Sun, Feb 8, 2009 at 7:27 PM, Eli Billauer wrote: > As far as I've seen, it tells the user to check the policy for refund. > It can very well be to cancel the whole deal, for a refund of the whole > sum. And the software can also be considered a present. I mean, suppose > that you go to the sup

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Eli Billauer
Dotan Cohen wrote: > The hole here is that he is not expected to read the Windows EULA > until it is explicitly presented to him at first boot. He could _then_ > decide to reject the license and contact Dell. It also says, > explicitly in the license, that the end user has the right to deny the >

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Dotan Cohen
> If they're not doing so voluntarily, yes. A computer vendor, like any > vendor, has a group of people which should have a synchronized view of > what they are selling and supporting. The more complicated the picture > gets, the more flavors the products have, the more resources they need > to mai

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Dan Shimshoni
Hi, >Somehow I had a feeling I was going to write another > message in this subject Strange, but me too!! >The laptop and the OS are bundled as a package deal, and you know it >when you buy the laptop. This is exactly the point: No always. As said here, why should a customer, who knows that he w

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Eli Billauer
Hello, Somehow I had a feeling I was going to write another message in this subject. Tzafrir Cohen wrote: > You mean: asking them to do what Dell already does today in Israel > (preload with FreeDOS) is too much? > > If they're not doing so voluntarily, yes. A computer vendor, like any ve

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Ilan Aisic
A year ago I have purchased a Dell laptop with "free dos" from Noa Computers (www.noacomp.co.il) in Nesher and we've installed Linux on it by ourselves. As far as I know, Dell offers this for some of its models. On Sun, Feb 8, 2009 at 2:27 PM, Dotan Cohen wrote: > > What do you suggest me ? >

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Dotan Cohen
> What do you suggest me ? > Buy the laptop with Vista, then get a Windows refund. Make sure that you take pictures of the first boot and take pictures of you declining the MS licence. That's what I did (in January 2007) but I never applied for the refund. -- Dotan Cohen http://what-is-what.com

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Tzafrir Cohen
On Sun, Feb 08, 2009 at 11:33:16AM +0200, Eli Billauer wrote: > Dan Shimshoni wrote: > > > The struggle must go on! > > > > > Sincerely, I don't know what for. The situation is not going to change > because a very small group of people starts to bother computer stores > with an unusual reques

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Sorana Fraier
Eli, why pay for an OS when you don't use it. Everyone has the right to choose whatever OS he wants, be it windows XP, linux, windows server 2003 or even for the sake of the argument buy a new laptop to use it for parts. I will elaborate further, even the seller can earn more from this. Lets say h

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread yossi arbel
Eli, >My bet is that Linux will become mainstream because non-computer >oriented companies with more than 10 computers will discover the >advantage of maintaining the computers with Linux on them. And once >ordinary people start to get used to it, the barrier is away. > This is slowly happening,

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Eli Billauer
Dan Shimshoni wrote: > The struggle must go on! > > Sincerely, I don't know what for. The situation is not going to change because a very small group of people starts to bother computer stores with an unusual request. Asking to check the laptop for Linux compatibility with a Live CD makes se

Re: [Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-08 Thread Tzafrir Cohen
On Sun, Feb 08, 2009 at 09:52:47AM +0200, Dan Shimshoni wrote: > Hi everybody, > > Reminder: > On 3.12.08, we heard about Zvi Devir and his "Successful Windows Vista > refund" - see: > http://www.mail-archive.com/haifux@haifux.org/msg03372.html > > And later, there was a lecture in Haifux by Zvi

[Haifux] "Windows-Free" laptops in Haifa

2009-02-07 Thread Dan Shimshoni
Hi everybody, Reminder: On 3.12.08, we heard about Zvi Devir and his "Successful Windows Vista refund" - see: http://www.mail-archive.com/haifux@haifux.org/msg03372.html And later, there was a lecture in Haifux by Zvi Devir about it: see: http://www.mail-archive.com/haifux@haifux.org/msg03451.ht