Re: [homenet] Creating a security association via physical link + button

2011-11-22 Thread Ted Lemon
On Nov 22, 2011, at 7:42 AM, Russ White wrote: This is, generally speaking, how current home routers work... And, I think, it might be the only way to make a homenet work. The primary key beyond this is a device being able to figure out I'm an edge to the outside world. Yeah, I don't think

Re: [homenet] Creating a security association via physical link + button

2011-11-22 Thread Randy Turner
Home routers with a natural WAN interface such as DSL or Docsis are built from reference designs that hardwire the internet interface, including any firewall-like functionality Randy Original message Subject: Re: [homenet] Creating a security association via physical link +

Re: [homenet] Creating a security association via physical link + button

2011-11-22 Thread Howard, Lee
A physical button, or a virtual button? I don't want to do mechanical engineering here. And buttons are expensive. Lee From: homenet-boun...@ietf.org [mailto:homenet-boun...@ietf.org] On Behalf Of Lorenzo Colitti Sent: Tuesday, November 22, 2011 3:02 AM To: homenet@ietf.org Subject: [homenet]

[homenet] other routing options

2011-11-22 Thread Howard, Lee
Ray asked for people to post drafts for anything other than OSPF, because without an alternative, it will appear that we have consensus on OSPF. I haven't posted a draft on RIPng, because it would just work the way it's designed. A few people said

Re: [homenet] other routing options

2011-11-22 Thread Randy Turner
On the point of autoconfig…in future references to OSPF, can I substitute zOSPF ? I'm assuming that we're not talking about deploying an off-the-shelf OSPF implementation because of the configuration impact on a home network consumer. So I was also assuming that I could substitute zOSPF

Re: [homenet] other routing options

2011-11-22 Thread Laurent Toutain
On Tue, Nov 22, 2011 at 23:36, Howard, Lee lee.how...@twcable.com wrote: Ray asked for people to post drafts for anything other than OSPF, because without an alternative, it will appear that we have consensus on OSPF. I haven't posted a draft on RIPng, because it would just work the way it's

Re: [homenet] other routing options

2011-11-22 Thread Mark Townsley
On Nov 23, 2011, at 8:10 AM, Randy Turner wrote: We still have the ongoing discussion of how to make all this auto-configurable... Which I think is the more significant piece And why we cannot simply accept just use RIPng on its own. We have to see what any routing protocol is going to