Re: reasons to NOT use EDEV

2008-02-21 Thread Rob van der Heij
On Thu, Feb 21, 2008 at 2:27 AM, Alan Altmark [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hard evidence of the performance of emulated FBA can be found at: http://www.vm.ibm.com/perf/reports/zvm/html/530scsi.html Don't just look at the tables; read the text that goes with them. Since I have not been able

Re: reasons to NOT use EDEV

2008-02-20 Thread Raymond Higgs
The IBM z/VM Operating System IBMVM@LISTSERV.UARK.EDU wrote on 02/19/2008 04:53:22 PM: Given that performance is very nearly the same between SAN and EDEV connections, or acceptably so, then I would recommend that you go with the EDEV approach. Just have your SAN folks carve out a big chunk

reasons to NOT use EDEV

2008-02-19 Thread Richard Troth
I should post this to the Linux list also, but I'll start with the VM list. On a VM system hosting Linux guests, I can think of one or two reasons why one might want to use EDEV instead of direct SAN connections. There are also some reasons why one would NOT want to. Can any of you think of

Re: reasons to NOT use EDEV

2008-02-19 Thread Adam Thornton
On Feb 19, 2008, at 3:33 PM, Richard Troth wrote: I should post this to the Linux list also, but I'll start with the VM list. On a VM system hosting Linux guests, I can think of one or two reasons why one might want to use EDEV instead of direct SAN connections. There are also some reasons

Re: reasons to NOT use EDEV

2008-02-19 Thread Dave Jones
Given that performance is very nearly the same between SAN and EDEV connections, or acceptably so, then I would recommend that you go with the EDEV approach. Just have your SAN folks carve out a big chunk of SAN storage for your use, and then allocate EDEV (FBA type) disk storage for guests as

Re: reasons to NOT use EDEV

2008-02-19 Thread Kris Buelens
As far as I know, EDEV -FBA emulation- uses much more CPU. At the other hand, with EDEV VM's minidisk cache becomes available, what can help Linuxes with shared minidisks. And there are differences in error recovery for the paths: -if I remember well- Linux does it better than CP. 2008/2/19,