Partially agree.
Just requiring a draft (that was not submitted within the meeting week) gives
you a two-week waiting period. I'm not so sure about the mailing list
requirement.
One of the best presentations-posing-as-barBoF in IETF 77 was about a traceback
experiment in Japan. They did writ
Dear Joel;
On Aug 1, 2010, at 10:08 AM, Joel M. Halpern wrote:
In hallway discussion about this, it was suggested to me that part
of the problem is that some folks can not figure out how to
socialize their ideas.
I would say that if a BarBOF is organized independent of the IETF
process
On Aug 2, 2010, at 5:48 PM, Marshall Eubanks wrote:
> Dear Joel;
>
> On Aug 1, 2010, at 10:08 AM, Joel M. Halpern wrote:
>
>> In hallway discussion about this, it was suggested to me that part
>> of the problem is that some folks can not figure out how to
>> socialize their ideas.
>>
>
>
In the case of the 2 BarBOFS I organized at IETF-78, in both cases
there were very useful contributions made by people I didn't know and
therefore wouldn't have invited. Even if the efforts fail (and one of
them was DOA and will not move forward), I am glad to have had the
opportunity to get to k
I am encountering two cases of Contributions where I am uncertain what my rights
are.
One is when material is not posted directly to an IETF list, rather a URL is
provided in an e-mail to a WG list, pointing to a Word or pdf document or a page
on a web site. Do the contents of such a document cou
On 8/2/2010 7:49 AM, t.petch wrote:
> I am encountering two cases of Contributions where I am uncertain what my
> rights
> are.
>
> One is when material is not posted directly to an IETF list, rather a URL is
> provided in an e-mail to a WG list, pointing to a Word or pdf document or a
> page
>
>One is when material is not posted directly to an IETF list, rather a
>URL is provided in an e-mail to a WG list, pointing to a Word or pdf
>document or a page on a web site. Do the contents of such a document
>count as a Contribution? Can I use the text from such a document in
>my own I-D? RFC
On Aug 2, 2010, at 6:16 PM, Spencer Dawkins wrote:
>>> In the case of the 2 BarBOFS I organized at IETF-78, in both cases
>>> there were very useful contributions made by people I didn't know and
>>> therefore wouldn't have invited. Even if the efforts fail (and one of
>>> them was DOA and will
