Re: Correct options for export

2001-07-13 Thread Ingolf Steinbach
On Thursday, 12. July 2001 23:45, Eric Siegerman wrote: Better would be to add an f suboption to -k: - -kv would be changed as we're discussing, to say override the stored keyword setting, except for 'b' - -kvf would do what -kv does now -- always overrides the stored

Re: Correct options for export

2001-07-12 Thread Ingolf Steinbach
On Wednesday, 11. July 2001 20:57, Mike Castle wrote: So when are you going to contribute the code that does it? That is *one* aspect. But I fear that -- even if someone did provide a patch (+ ChangeLog entry + sanity test case + ...) -- there might quite a good chance that the time was wasted

Re: Correct options for export

2001-07-12 Thread Ingolf Steinbach
On Thursday, 12. July 2001 07:46, Greg A. Woods wrote: Well, duh. Doctor! Doctor! It hurts when I bang my head on the wall! Greg, I think this is not exactly the right comparison (I hope, my doctor would not suggest that I may bang my head on the wall if I want to and that I then would feel

Re: Correct options for export

2001-07-12 Thread Mike Castle
On Thu, Jul 12, 2001 at 09:24:58PM +0200, Ingolf Steinbach wrote: Is there consensus among the developers with write access to the CVS source that the cases in which a file which was added with -kb needs to be checked out / updated / exported with keyword handling any other than -kb are so

Re: Correct options for export

2001-07-12 Thread Larry Jones
Ingolf Steinbach writes: That is *one* aspect. But I fear that -- even if someone did provide a patch (+ ChangeLog entry + sanity test case + ...) -- there might quite a good chance that the time was wasted because it would be rejected. Is there consensus among the developers with write

Re: Correct options for export

2001-07-12 Thread Greg A. Woods
[ On Thursday, July 12, 2001 at 21:52:42 (+0200), Ingolf Steinbach wrote: ] Subject: Re: Correct options for export Greg, I think this is not exactly the right comparison (I hope, my doctor would not suggest that I may bang my head on the wall if I want to and that I then would feel only

Re: Correct options for export

2001-07-12 Thread Eric Siegerman
On Thu, Jul 12, 2001 at 09:52:42PM +0200, Ingolf Steinbach wrote: Are there situations in which a file is added with -kb to a repository other than because it is a binary file? Because the person adding it made a mistake :-) But the right way to fix that mistake is to use cvs admin -kwhatever

Re: Correct options for export

2001-07-12 Thread Eric Siegerman
On Thu, Jul 12, 2001 at 05:09:03PM -0400, Greg A. Woods wrote: [ On Thursday, July 12, 2001 at 21:52:42 (+0200), Ingolf Steinbach wrote: ] The problem is that you can't turn off the features in CVS that are hard (impossible) to use once you've added binary files to a repository. What

Re: Correct options for export and binary files

2001-07-12 Thread Bruce Hill
Eric Siegerman wrote: The two worms I can think of are: - The -kb mechanism is fragile, and when it breaks, the file gets corrupted. Well, that's what this thread is about fixing. - No reserved checkouts. That's clearly a problem for unmergeable files (whether binary

Re: Correct options for export

2001-07-12 Thread Greg A. Woods
[ On Thursday, July 12, 2001 at 18:18:58 (-0700), Schwenk, Jeanie wrote: ] Subject: Re: Correct options for export I've been following this never-ending thread and simply put, the storage of binary files is sometimes a necessity. So? Store them! Just not in CVS if you want to avoid

Re: Correct options for export

2001-07-12 Thread Greg A. Woods
[ On Thursday, July 12, 2001 at 18:11:46 (-0400), Eric Siegerman wrote: ] Subject: Re: Correct options for export On Thu, Jul 12, 2001 at 05:09:03PM -0400, Greg A. Woods wrote: The problem is that you can't turn off the features in CVS that are hard (impossible) to use once you've added

Correct options for export

2001-07-11 Thread Ingolf Steinbach
Hi, people keep suggesting to use -kv keyword substitution with export. I'd definitly like to use it, but we have some binary files in the repository which might be corrupted during export -kv (see also http://cvshome.org/docs/manual/cvs_12.html#SEC102). What is the reason that the -k option is

Re: Correct options for export

2001-07-11 Thread Mike Castle
On Wed, Jul 11, 2001 at 08:00:23PM +0200, Ingolf Steinbach wrote: if they were checked in as binary? I believe that many users would appreciate a change which ignores -k for binary files. So when are you going to contribute the code that does it? mrc -- Mike Castle [EMAIL

Re: Correct options for export

2001-07-11 Thread Greg A. Woods
[ On Wednesday, July 11, 2001 at 20:00:23 (+0200), Ingolf Steinbach wrote: ] Subject: Correct options for export people keep suggesting to use -kv keyword substitution with export. I'd definitly like to use it, but we have some binary files in the repository which might be corrupted during