Hi,
I'm a bit uncomfortable with the requirement that IKE peer MUST
advertise NAT device port if it is reachable and MUST NOT
if it isn't. I think, that IKE Initiator in most cases cannot
reliably determine whether it is reachable or not. For example,
even if you manually configured port
Hello,
I have a few comments.
- The Introduction says that It turns out using EC groups in
some scenarios require...additional tests. This document
defines these tests. Well the memo is defining more than
EC. I think the Intro should introduce us to the why, which
is
Hi Steve Vishwas,
Here are a couple of comments on the proposed -02 sent a few days ago.
Requirement 1 says gateways and endpoints MUST minimize configuration changes
when a new gateway or endpoint is added, removed or changed. While I certainly
agree with the sentiment behind the
I made a mistake below. Thanks to Dan Brown for pointing it out.
On Tue, December 11, 2012 10:06 am, Dan Harkins wrote:
[snip]
- I think it should be mentioned that elliptic curve groups
have a co-factor, h, and if h 1 that a further check is
also required, namely, if the x-
