Re: [IPsec] Issue #57: Clarify D-H transform

2009-05-05 Thread Tero Kivinen
Yaron Sheffer writes: Hi Tero, Sec. 3.3.2 mentions that you negotiate a D-H group for ESP/AH, even though you only need encryption and integrity transforms for these protocols. I find it confusing, certainly for newcomers. For clarity, I suggest to add after the table in Sec. 3.3.3, this

[IPsec] Issue #57: Clarify D-H transform

2009-05-04 Thread Tero Kivinen
Yaron Sheffer writes: Yaron: 3.3.2: there is no explanation here or elsewhere that the D-H transform for ESP and AH is used for PFS. Paul (off list): Not done. I don't think it belongs in 3.3.2, and I also don't agree that the transform is the D-H transform for ESP and AH is used for

[IPsec] Issue #57: Clarify D-H transform

2009-05-03 Thread Yaron Sheffer
Yaron: 3.3.2: there is no explanation here or elsewhere that the D-H transform for ESP and AH is used for PFS. Paul (off list): Not done. I don't think it belongs in 3.3.2, and I also don't agree that the transform is the D-H transform for ESP and AH is used for PFS; that's an