Re: [BEHAVE] address-format: bits 64 to 71

2009-12-21 Thread GangChen
2009/12/21 Christian Huitema huit...@microsoft.com If WKP(64:FF9B::/96) is the consensus, it better to state clearly that WKP should not apply U/G requirements in the draft, right? The U/G bits in 64:FF9B::/96 are set to zero, so there is no need for an exception. This is not an

Re: [BEHAVE] address-format: bits 64 to 71

2009-12-20 Thread GangChen
My question is: Should the IPv4-embeded IPv6 address still be in accordance with the specification defined in RFC4291 as ...For all unicast addresses, except those that start with the binary value 000, Interface IDs are required to be 64 bits long and to be constructed in Modified EUI-64

RE: [BEHAVE] address-format: bits 64 to 71

2009-12-20 Thread Christian Huitema
I have a concern about that specified rule of bits 64 to 71 doesn't protect the semantics of the u/g bit. In the case of adopting WKP, the U-bits should be 1, since WKP is only concatenated with global IPv4 address to guarantee the uniqueness of IPv4-Converted IPv6 addresses.

Re: [BEHAVE] address-format: bits 64 to 71

2009-12-09 Thread Jeroen Massar
Xu Xiaohu wrote: Since the following email is not successfully received by some subscribers, so I resend it. You might want to try and subscribe to ipv6@ietf.org to resolve part of that issue, otherwise everytime you sent something it ends up in the moderation queue Greets, Jeroen

RE: [BEHAVE] address-format: bits 64 to 71

2009-12-09 Thread Wojciech Dec (wdec)
] address-format: bits 64 to 71 Xu Xiaohu wrote : The following statement is quoted from RFC 4291: IPv6 nodes are not required to validate that interface identifiers created with modified EUI-64 tokens with the u bit set to universal are unique. The use of the universal/local bit

Re: [BEHAVE] address-format: bits 64 to 71

2009-12-09 Thread Rémi Després
Wojciech Dec (wdec) wrote: Indeed, not checking uniqueness of IPv6 addresses when they are MAC-address derived would be a bad idea: MAC addresses cannot be assumed to be really universal because they can be administratively configured in some hosts. Under the EUI-64 scheme, a non unique