RE: IPv6 Books (Re: An example of what is wrong with the IETF's IPv6 documentation)

2007-10-25 Thread michael.dillon
> Maybe a wiki or other online / real-time solution would be > best, but this will require someone to manage it and people > who have a clue to monitor (moderate) it, and most of these > people are either doing it or are working on improving it ( > i.e. writing RFCs). I think this is the reaso

Re: IPv6 Books (Re: An example of what is wrong with the IETF's IPv6 documentation)

2007-10-25 Thread Eric Klein
On 10/24/07, [EMAIL PROTECTED] <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > > I'm not so arrogant as to claim I am all-knowing. That doesn't help win > technical arguments. And although I can deal with my own educational > needs by plodding through RFCs and books etc., that doesn't help me find > a concise o

Re: IPv6 Books (Re: An example of what is wrong with the IETF's IPv6 documentation)

2007-10-24 Thread David Malone
On Wed, Oct 24, 2007 at 03:30:50PM +0100, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > I don't think you understand the situation. There are loads of people > with many years of deep IPv4 experience under their belt. They have > gotten used to understanding networks and being right when they make > design tradeoffs.

Re: IPv6 Books (Re: An example of what is wrong with the IETF's IPv6 documentation)

2007-10-24 Thread JORDI PALET MARTINEZ
Responder a: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Fecha: Wed, 24 Oct 2007 17:09:00 +0200 (CEST) > Para: Jeroen Massar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > CC: , Mohsen Souissi <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Asunto: Re: IPv6 Books (Re: An example of what is wrong with the IETF's IPv6 > documentation) &g

Re: IPv6 Books (Re: An example of what is wrong with the IETF's IPv6 documentation)

2007-10-24 Thread Mohacsi Janos
Hi, I can recommend one book also "IPv6 deployment guide" available in pdf: from http://www.6journal.org/archive/0148/ or http://www.6diss.org/publications/info/deployment-guide.pdf Best Regards, Janos Mohacsi Network Engineer, Research Associate, Head of Network Planning and Projects NIIF

RE: IPv6 Books (Re: An example of what is wrong with the IETF's IPv6 documentation)

2007-10-24 Thread michael.dillon
> Next to that they also have technical reviewers and nowadays > in the age of the Internet there are sites where reviews are > given about the books and you can base your opinion on that too. I've seen enough inaccuracies in books that I don't really trust the technical review process of publi

Re: IPv6 Books (Re: An example of what is wrong with the IETF's IPv6 documentation)

2007-10-24 Thread Jeroen Massar
Alexandru Petrescu wrote: > A book I'm pondering over, buying it maybe one day: > > IPv6 Advanced Protocols Implementation > at Morgan-Kaufmann of Elsevier > http://tinyurl.com/2cetvh Did not see that one before, but I see one important name on the book, Jinmei, and as such indeed, if you are look

Re: IPv6 Books (Re: An example of what is wrong with the IETF's IPv6 documentation)

2007-10-24 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 24-okt-2007, at 14:21, <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Was it, or any of the other books on your list, vetted by enough eyes to be trusted? Books have technical reviewers before publication and reviews in publications and on sites like amazon.com after publication. So I

Re: IPv6 Books (Re: An example of what is wrong with the IETF's IPv6 documentation)

2007-10-24 Thread Alexandru Petrescu
A book I'm pondering over, buying it maybe one day: IPv6 Advanced Protocols Implementation at Morgan-Kaufmann of Elsevier http://tinyurl.com/2cetvh Alex Jeroen Massar wrote: Mohsen Souissi wrote: [..] ==> See also the native-French-wiki book: http://livre.g6.asso.fr/ (from the Book "IPv6, The

RE: IPv6 Books (Re: An example of what is wrong with the IETF's IPv6 documentation)

2007-10-24 Thread michael.dillon
> Also online: http://www.ip6.com/us/book/index.html (first hit > for google > (ipv6 book) btw. I've already mentioned that one on http://www.getipv6.info but I can't say that it is recommended unless I learn more about it. I trust Brian Carpenter's recommendation due to his history with the IET

IPv6 Books (Re: An example of what is wrong with the IETF's IPv6 documentation)

2007-10-24 Thread Jeroen Massar
Mohsen Souissi wrote: [..] > ==> See also the native-French-wiki book: http://livre.g6.asso.fr/ > (from the Book "IPv6, Theorie et pratique", O'Reilly, 4th Edition). > > | are pretty much up to date. > > ==> so is the book online... Also online: http://www.ip6.com/us/book/index.html (first hit