Re: [j-nsp] MVPN Interoperability Issue

2009-10-19 Thread Phil Mayers
Harry Reynolds wrote: For draft rosen I would suggest gre rather than mpls p-2-mp. Not sure that latter is even supported. There are a few other interop notes, but depends on if you plan rosen6 or rosen7. In either case, you need to have a lo0.x with the same ip as the main instance lo0 in

Re: [j-nsp] MVPN Interoperability Issue

2009-10-19 Thread Harry Reynolds
Reynolds Cc: Stefan Fouant; Juniper List Subject: Re: [j-nsp] MVPN Interoperability Issue Harry Reynolds wrote: For draft rosen I would suggest gre rather than mpls p-2-mp. Not sure that latter is even supported. There are a few other interop notes, but depends on if you plan rosen6 or rosen7

[j-nsp] MVPN Interoperability Issue

2009-10-16 Thread Stefan Fouant
Anyone on list have any success setting up Multicast over BGP-MPLS VPNs in a heterogenous environment consisting of both Juniper and Cisco routers? Basically, I've got Juniper MX running as PE router with Cisco 7600s as P router. I don't think Cisco supports NG-VPN yet, so I'm trying to get

Re: [j-nsp] MVPN Interoperability Issue

2009-10-16 Thread Harry Reynolds
: juniper-nsp-boun...@puck.nether.net [mailto:juniper-nsp-boun...@puck.nether.net] On Behalf Of Stefan Fouant Sent: Friday, October 16, 2009 10:47 AM To: Juniper List Subject: [j-nsp] MVPN Interoperability Issue Anyone on list have any success setting up Multicast over BGP-MPLS VPNs in a heterogenous

Re: [j-nsp] MVPN Interoperability Issue

2009-10-16 Thread John Frame
...@puck.nether.net] On Behalf Of Stefan Fouant Sent: Friday, October 16, 2009 10:47 AM To: Juniper List Subject: [j-nsp] MVPN Interoperability Issue Anyone on list have any success setting up Multicast over BGP-MPLS VPNs in a heterogenous environment consisting of both Juniper and Cisco routers

Re: [j-nsp] MVPN Interoperability Issue

2009-10-16 Thread Stefan Fouant
On Fri, Oct 16, 2009 at 3:17 PM, John Frame jfr...@juniper.net wrote: Actually it is possible to support BGP-MVPNs over a non-P2MP capable core by using GRE tunnels. Each PE would require a Tunnel PIC to support both the GRE requirement and the vt interface must be used in the routing

Re: [j-nsp] MVPN Interoperability Issue

2009-10-16 Thread Stefan Fouant
Great! Thanks for all the feedback... Now its off to the lab for me to get this running... which may ultimately lead me to recommend swapping out the 7600 P Routers for Juniper MXs. :) Cheers, On 10/16/09, John Frame jfr...@juniper.net wrote: Yes, you only need a single GRE tunnel between PEs