Re: [lace] Re: lFantasy Flowers

2004-05-19 Thread Faye Owers
: Wednesday, May 19, 2004 2:32 PM Subject: Re: [lace] Re: lFantasy Flowers I'm not able to comment on these opinions, as I'm not familiar with either book - but I do think it is most unfair to make accusations like this when Rosemary is out of the country and can't defend herself. Ruth Budge

Re: [lace] Re: lFantasy Flowers

2004-05-19 Thread Laceandbits
In a message dated 19/05/2004 16:38:55 GMT Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: What you are all saying is that it is OK to take someone's work and use it for one's own material gain? That isn't how I read the posts on this subject at all. What they do all seem to be saying is that it

RE: [lace] Re: lFantasy Flowers

2004-05-19 Thread Panza, Robin
If Rosemary made her first flowers in the late 70s then this predates the Novak ones by a considerable margin. But no-one would think that plagiarism has taken place the other way round, would they! Frankly, that was my first reaction--that it could have just as easily been plagiarism in either

Re: [lace] Re: lFantasy Flowers

2004-05-19 Thread Weronika Patena
Hi, I have nothing to say on the similar flowers, since I haven't seen either book, but one of the emails made me wonder about something else: that we should respect the fact. I am quite sceptical at the suggestion that two people design the same piece, maybe in Torchon but not in Free lace.

RE: [lace] Re: lFantasy Flowers

2004-05-19 Thread Patricia Dowden
- From: Weronika Patena [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, May 19, 2004 5:02 PM To: Karolina Jeffers Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [lace] Re: lFantasy Flowers Hi, I have nothing to say on the similar flowers, since I haven't seen either book, but one of the emails made me wonder

Re: [lace] Re: lFantasy Flowers

2004-05-18 Thread Ruth Budge
I'm not able to comment on these opinions, as I'm not familiar with either book - but I do think it is most unfair to make accusations like this when Rosemary is out of the country and can't defend herself. Ruth Budge (Sydney, Australia) Karolina Jeffers [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I had a look at