2. If you manage to do your pre-processing in a way that only mixes your
static network data with OSM, resulting in a data structure that
contains information like transit from stop X to stop Y possible for
these types of vehicles and so on, and then your router process, upon
startup, reads this
Hi Frederick,
However, in terms of ODbL the
route description they produce will be a produced work which is based on
a database derived from OSM
a derivative database that is only used to create a Produced Work is
excluded from the share-alike:
4.5 Limits of Share Alike. The requirements of
Hello everybody,
I am still concerned that some business users cannot make use of
OpenStreetMap data because of the Share-Alike-rule as they don't want or
cannot share proprietary data. Personally, I am a big fan of the
Share-Alike-rule but I think there should be some exceptions.
I have the
So, in summary:
- No attribution
- Is a derived work released under Copyright
I assume this hasn't been cleared and 'waived' by someone at OSM? Where can
we go from here?
I think that in cases where we can prove such a 'mistake' we should send
them a letter and clearly indicate their wrong
Dear Mr President, I've got this photo showing you in bed with another
man, here's my bank account where you can make a donation, in which case
will forget about it...
... unless I need more money later in which case I might again remember?
Honestly, what you're suggesting smacks of blackmail.
1. Is it clear that a map tile is an image within the definition of a
Produced Work--a work (such as an image...) resulting from using the
whole or a Substantial part of the Contents?If not, what is the most
typical example of a Produced Work in the map context?
Consider a produced work of
What you're saying, basically, is that making a cake loses the (or some)
properties of the ingredients, thus a produced work; making a car
doesn't, thus not produced. (Of course making a car also entails
irreversible actions but let's ignore that for the moment.)
Transferred back to the map