Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-20 Thread Pavol Luptak
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA256 No, it's not their own fault. But you cannot force people (using aggression) to help poor people. But you can ask them to do it and explain them why voluntary supporting poor people is really important. Solidarity has to be voluntary, otherwise i

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-05 Thread Maxim Kammerer
On Mon, Nov 5, 2012 at 4:34 PM, Yosem Companys wrote: > While I (and probably others) find the discussion on this thread > interesting, it appears to lack the necessary technology component to be > deemed liberationtech. I am not sure the situation is that simple. I believe (this is a long thread

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-05 Thread Greg Norcie
The personal (computer) is political :) -- Greg Norcie (g...@norcie.com) GPG key: 0x1B873635 On 11/5/12 1:21 PM, Yosem Companys wrote: > They go hand in hand. Can't have philosophy without practices... ;) > > On Mon, Nov 5, 2012 at 10:12 AM, Dmytri Kleiner wrote: >> Hey Yosem, pretty sure the t

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-05 Thread Yosem Companys
They go hand in hand. Can't have philosophy without practices... ;) On Mon, Nov 5, 2012 at 10:12 AM, Dmytri Kleiner wrote: > Hey Yosem, pretty sure the thread has run its course at this point. But in > any case we can't get the tech part right if we don't get the liberation > part right. > > The

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-05 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
Hey Yosem, pretty sure the thread has run its course at this point. But in any case we can't get the tech part right if we don't get the liberation part right.  The user stories for liberation tech must certainly derive from visions of liberation, or?  Especially when the tech in question is e

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-05 Thread Yosem Companys
Just a little nudge to get folks back on the liberationtech discussion. While I (and probably others) find the discussion on this thread interesting, it appears to lack the necessary technology component to be deemed liberationtech. Thanks all, Yosem On Mon, Nov 5, 2012 at 4:15 AM, André Rebent

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-05 Thread André Rebentisch
Am 05.11.2012 11:19, schrieb Jacob Appelbaum: > It isn't a straw man. Free trade is a nonsense phrase - free? Free for > you? For me? Unencumbered by state taxes as it crosses a border? How > does that trade happen? When I create something of value - have I done > it in a vacuum? "Free trade" rela

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-05 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 05.11.2012 11:19, Jacob Appelbaum wrote: until people have an alternative, people will not choose to starve. Thanks Jake! That sums it it perfectly. Thanks to Maxim and Gregory for their contributions as well. Best, -- Dmytri Kleiner Venture Communist -- Unsubscribe, change to digest,

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-05 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 05.11.2012 06:23, StealthMonger wrote: True, except that those functions are mostly not socially necessary. This is well know to be false, and ridiculous. You yourself, could probably not survive without the benefits provided by the state. I don't mean you can't imagine yourself surviving

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-05 Thread Jacob Appelbaum
StealthMonger: > Dmytri Kleiner writes: > >> We can not eliminate the State-based tax system by evading it, only >> by replacing the socially necessary functions it performs with >> actually-existing non-state forms, an unwillingness to understand >> and come to terms with this is what makes so m

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-04 Thread StealthMonger
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Dmytri Kleiner writes: > We can not eliminate the State-based tax system by evading it, only > by replacing the socially necessary functions it performs with > actually-existing non-state forms, an unwillingness to understand > and come to terms with

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-04 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 04.11.2012 00:53, StealthMonger wrote: Bitcoin prevents inflation and helps tax evation [sic] (the system itself is hard to regulate) [3] Bitcoin is not unique at being useful for tax evasion, in fact it's not even popular among large scale tax evaders, who have better means. In an

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-03 Thread StealthMonger
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Gregory Maxwell writes: > On Tue, Oct 30, 2012 at 9:51 PM, StealthMonger > wrote: >> Yes, Bitcoin liberates trade from "public" extortion ("taxation"). > It does no such thing. Not true. Look at the sources: ... Bitcoin can be considered to b

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-02 Thread Gregory Maxwell
On Tue, Oct 30, 2012 at 9:51 PM, StealthMonger wrote: > Yes, Bitcoin liberates trade from "public" extortion ("taxation"). It does no such thing. Under US law, for example, Barter in Bitcoins is just as taxable as bartering with coal or cows and share many similar properties (also with cash). Ad

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-02 Thread Julian Oliver
..on Fri, Nov 02, 2012 at 06:03:24PM +0200, Maxim Kammerer wrote: > On Fri, Nov 2, 2012 at 4:20 PM, Julian Oliver wrote: > > Relatedly, I met a young woman in Abu Dhabi who said to me in a mall "You > > Westerners look around and see all these girls in full burkas and think > > they are > > trapp

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-02 Thread Maxim Kammerer
On Fri, Nov 2, 2012 at 4:20 PM, Julian Oliver wrote: > Relatedly, I met a young woman in Abu Dhabi who said to me in a mall "You > Westerners look around and see all these girls in full burkas and think they > are > trapped, oppressed under Islam. In fact they are only wearing full burkas here >

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-02 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 02.11.2012 14:19, StealthMonger wrote: My main quarrel would be that when he writes of doing things "as a society" he probably means single decisions applied to all and imposed on dissidents by force. Yes, sometimes single decisions are needed. Such as the descision that poluting the r

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-02 Thread Julian Oliver
..on Fri, Nov 02, 2012 at 04:59:15AM +, dan jones wrote: > > If I may elucidate this thought by cut and pasting the words of David > Foster-Wallace, personal liberty is... > > "The freedom all to be lords of our tiny skull-sized kingdoms, alone at > the center of all creation. This kind of fr

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-02 Thread StealthMonger
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Jacob Appelbaum writes: > Care to address the externalities on our all of our lives that others, > such as you, impose by their mere existence? Maybe that can mostly be brought within the scope of "Relations among individuals should be by mutual con

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-02 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 01.11.2012 21:04, StealthMonger wrote: Dmytri Kleiner writes: So you believe that we should provide nothing as a society ... I certainly don't. You are free to delegate your authority to your comrades in matters such as your own health care or the education of your own children. Just

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-02 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 01.11.2012 21:04, StealthMonger wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Dmytri Kleiner writes: So you believe that we should provide nothing as a society ... I certainly don't. You are free to delegate your authority to your comrades in matters such as your own health car

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-01 Thread dan jones
Jacob Appelbaum: > StealthMonger: >> Dmytri Kleiner writes: >> >>> So you believe that we should provide nothing as a society ... >> >>> I certainly don't. >> >> You are free to delegate your authority to your comrades in matters >> such as your own health care or the education of your own childre

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-01 Thread Dev Random
Jumping into the fray... On 12-11-01 02:05 PM, Jacob Appelbaum wrote: > > Liberty requires acknowledging that other people exist and that we > aren't individual islands. > > Care to address the externalities on our all of our lives that others, > such as you, impose by their mere existence? I ful

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-01 Thread Jacob Appelbaum
StealthMonger: > Dmytri Kleiner writes: > >> So you believe that we should provide nothing as a society ... > >> I certainly don't. > > You are free to delegate your authority to your comrades in matters > such as your own health care or the education of your own children. > Just don't presume

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-01 Thread StealthMonger
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Dmytri Kleiner writes: > So you believe that we should provide nothing as a society ... > I certainly don't. You are free to delegate your authority to your comrades in matters such as your own health care or the education of your own children. Jus

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-11-01 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 31.10.2012 02:51, StealthMonger wrote: ... for example, [money] can be used to pay taxes. Taxation is a threat against which a liberated individual has to defend itself. So you believe that we should provide nothing as a society, on behalf of all, that their should be no public goods, and

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-10-30 Thread StealthMonger
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Dmytri Kleiner writes: > ... for example, [money] can be used to pay taxes. Taxation is a threat against which a liberated individual has to defend itself. > ... the State is clearly unsatisfactory for modern publics as a > result of the fact that

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-10-30 Thread liberationtech
On Tue, Oct 30, 2012 at 10:10:22PM +0100, d...@telekommunisten.net wrote 7.5K bytes in 143 lines about: : Does Bitcoin have the potential to replace Government fiat money? I assume you've seen http://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/other/virtualcurrencyschemes201210en.pdf -- Andrew http://tpo.is/cont

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-10-30 Thread Douglas Lucas
view. Sent on the Sprint® Now Network from my > BlackBerry® > > -Original Message- From: Bill Woodcock Date: > Tue, 30 Oct 2012 18:42:51 To: > Subject: Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of > Money > > > > On Oct 30, 2012, at 2:10 PM, Dmytri K

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-10-30 Thread Pavol Luptak
May be a bit different and interesting Bitcoin and government presentation: http://shadowlife.cc/files/btcotc.pdf It was one of the most shocking presentation I saw at the Bitcoin conference 2012 in London. Pavol On Tue, Oct 30, 2012 at 10:10:22PM +0100, Dmytri Kleiner wrote: > > I want to wri

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-10-30 Thread elham gheytanchi
2012 18:42:51 To: Subject: Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money On Oct 30, 2012, at 2:10 PM, Dmytri Kleiner wrote: > The critical feature required of public money is that we can socially > determine how much of it there is, and how much of we want to apply to p

Re: [liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-10-30 Thread Bill Woodcock
On Oct 30, 2012, at 2:10 PM, Dmytri Kleiner wrote: > The critical feature required of public money is that we can socially > determine how much of it there is, and how much of we want to apply to public > purpose. We need ways to create and destroy public money so that we can can > have a coun

[liberationtech] Bitcoin and The Public Function of Money

2012-10-30 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
I want to write a bit about the public function of money, especially as compared to the market function of money, in light of some of the recent discussion about Bitcoin. Bitcoin is already a very useful technology due to the fact that it allows transactions to take place without any central