I'm not an AnCap myself, at least not yet, but it certainly seems to be
you are equating lack of a state with lack of law. I'll leave it to the
philosophers among us to go into detail, but it certainly doesn't seem
to me that the one flows from the other. Would you as an individual
stand by
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-
Hash: SHA1
On Tuesday 29 July 2008, Inibo E. Exibo was heard to say:
I'm not an AnCap myself, at least not yet, but it certainly seems
to be you are equating lack of a state with lack of law.
Indeed, many people subscribe to the Hobbsian war of all against
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Inibo E. Exibo
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
I'm not an AnCap myself, at least not yet, but it
certainly seems to be you are equating lack of a state
with lack of law.
I'll leave it to the philosophers among us to go
into detail, but it certainly
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Curt Howland
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Would you as an individual stand by and let someone be murdered if
you were able to stop it? If not, why do you think a society of
free people would?
Exactly.
Tanzanians wouldn't. They are standing
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Dennis Lee Wilson
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Your VERY FIRST COMMENT in this discussion thread was:
Here's another example of what would happen in an AnarchoCapitalist
paradise
And I stand by that. It ***WOULD*** happen in an AnarchoCapitalist
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Zack Bass [EMAIL PROTECTED]
wrote:
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Dennis Lee Wilson
dennisleewilson@ wrote:
Your VERY FIRST COMMENT in this discussion thread was:
Here's another example of what would happen in an
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Dennis Lee Wilson
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
It is NOT an example of what ***WOULD*** happen in an AnarchoCapitalist
paradise because an AnCap paradise ***would have armed citizens who
could defend themselves*** and others (if they so chose).
But
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Dennis Lee Wilson
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
It is NOT an example of what ***WOULD*** happen in an
AnarchoCapitalist paradise because an AnCap paradise
***would have armed citizens who
could defend themselves*** and others (if they so chose).
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Zack Bass [EMAIL PROTECTED]
wrote:
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Dennis Lee Wilson
dennisleewilson@ wrote:
It is NOT an example of what ***WOULD*** happen in an
AnarchoCapitalist
paradise because an AnCap paradise ***would
Curt Howland wrote:
I'm not trying to convert you to an-cap, don't worry. I think you will
find Roderick Long's Answers to 10 objections to anarchy to be
interesting in this context:
http://mises.org/mp3/MU2004/Long2.mp3
http://mises.org/mp3/MU2004/Long2.mp3
And Wouldn't The Warlords
From: Zack Bass [EMAIL PROTECTED]
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Dennis Lee Wilson
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
It is NOT an example of what ***WOULD*** happen in an
AnarchoCapitalist paradise because an AnCap paradise
***would have armed citizens who
could defend
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Statistics to date are that defense is a much better
deterant than retribution.
The very _possibility_ of defense is a better deterrant
than retribution.
Nope! Defense PLUS Retribution is a great deterrent. No one
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Robert D. Silvetz,
M.D. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Retribution undoubtedly has a deterrent effect.
But having non-victims capable AND willing to defend
themselves makes being a criminal quite dangerous
Amen.
But there are many situations
And in 2nd Am territory, two other Walmart employess draw their weapon and
shoot the SOB dead.
The very scenario you describe occured in Texas where a criminal thought he
could take down a waitress.
The owner saw what was happening and drew a shotgun on the perp. Of the five
patrons, two
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Robert D. Silvetz,
M.D. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
a criminal thought he could take down a waitress.
The owner saw what was happening and drew a shotgun on the perp. Of
the five patrons, two were carrying and drew their weapon the perp.
The
But Retribution doesn't prevent many of those now... the deterrent effect is
not particularly great for the line items below.
- Original Message -
From: Zack Bass
To: LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Tuesday, July 29, 2008 10:26 PM
Subject:
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Robert D. Silvetz,
M.D. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
After a fair number get lead poisonings, attempting
to hold people up except under the most advantageous
conditions, is just a losing -- and deadly -- proposition.
You guys have a very limited
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Zack Bass [EMAIL PROTECTED]
wrote:
In Kennesaw, crime has been deterred MORE by the addition of Defense
to Retribution. Get rid of Retribution for a week and we'll talk.
No we won't. Even *I* have limits.
You are simply dense Zack. Nobody here, (at least within the thread on my
emails here) is arguing against retribution. Just that it is insufficient on
its face.
So peace. Goto bed.
- Original Message -
From: Zack Bass
To: LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com
Sent:
Retribution works to some extent to deter those items, whereas
Self-Defense DOES NOT WORK AT ALL to deter those items.
--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, Robert D. Silvetz,
M.D. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
But Retribution doesn't prevent many of those now... the deterrent
effect is
Let me make it explicit and then I'm outta here: What they have stated
(several times) is that retribution is not primary. Self-defense is. Once
self-defense, full armed self-defense, is operative it is dangerous to be a
criminal. Period. End of story. That's reality AS IT IS.
Which
OF COURSE IT IS. THAT'S WHY THE OTHERS HAVE WEAPONS
Bye bye.
- Original Message -
From: Zack Bass
To: LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Tuesday, July 29, 2008 10:54 PM
Subject: [LibertarianEnterprise] Re: Albinos uninsurable in Tanzania
--- In
22 matches
Mail list logo
