Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-26 Thread Thomas Morley
2017-09-25 19:22 GMT+02:00 Phil Holmes : > - Original Message - From: "Shamus Hammons" > To: "Carl Sorensen" ; "David Kastrup" > Cc: > Sent: Monday, September 25, 2017 5:31 PM > Subject: Re: Problem with Codas >> >> >> Bas

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-25 Thread Wols Lists
On 25/09/17 18:22, Phil Holmes wrote: > There's no requirement for that blank space. Gould says that it may be > used, but does not state it should or must be. Personally, I've never > seen music set like that. Most of the music I've seen is set like that ... (not that codas are common in what I

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-25 Thread Phil Holmes
- Original Message - From: "Shamus Hammons" To: "Carl Sorensen" ; "David Kastrup" Cc: Sent: Monday, September 25, 2017 5:31 PM Subject: Re: Problem with Codas Basically, the coda should have some whitespace between it and the prior section of music and

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-25 Thread Shamus Hammons
On 09/20/2017 11:35 AM, Carl Sorensen wrote: > On 9/19/17 5:33 PM, "David Kastrup" wrote: > >> Shamus Hammons writes: >> >>> On 09/17/2017 01:50 AM, David Kastrup wrote: Carl Sorensen writes: > On 9/16/17 8:09 AM, "Shamus Hammons" wrote: > >> I have a dream, that one day

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-20 Thread Carl Sorensen
On 9/19/17 5:33 PM, "David Kastrup" wrote: >Shamus Hammons writes: > >> On 09/17/2017 01:50 AM, David Kastrup wrote: >>> Carl Sorensen writes: >>> On 9/16/17 8:09 AM, "Shamus Hammons" wrote: > I have a dream, that one day Lilypond will make codas first class > citizens inste

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-19 Thread David Kastrup
Shamus Hammons writes: > On 09/17/2017 01:50 AM, David Kastrup wrote: >> Carl Sorensen writes: >> >>> On 9/16/17 8:09 AM, "Shamus Hammons" wrote: >>> I have a dream, that one day Lilypond will make codas first class citizens instead of having to exist as a series of ugly hacks. In th

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-19 Thread Shamus Hammons
On 09/17/2017 01:50 AM, David Kastrup wrote: > Carl Sorensen writes: > >> On 9/16/17 8:09 AM, "Shamus Hammons" wrote: >> >>> I have a dream, that one day Lilypond will make codas first class >>> citizens instead of having to exist as a series of ugly hacks. In that >>> day, I could simply write

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-19 Thread Joel C. Salomon
On 2017-09-18 10:07 PM, Caagr98 wrote: > On 09/18/17 19:46, Joel C. Salomon wrote: >> Omitting the coda alternative, this would be the natural way to input >> repeats of the form “D.S. al Fine”.  I would suggest “\repeat ds” (and >> “\repeat dc”, unless you want to add magic that recognizes the sta

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-18 Thread Joel C. Salomon
On 2017-09-17 2:50 AM, David Kastrup wrote: > Carl Sorensen writes: >> On 9/16/17 8:09 AM, "Shamus Hammons" wrote: >> >>> I have a dream, that one day Lilypond will make codas first class >>> citizens instead of having to exist as a series of ugly hacks. In that >>> day, I could simply write \cod

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-18 Thread Caagr98
On 09/18/17 19:46, Joel C. Salomon wrote: Omitting the coda alternative, this would be the natural way to input repeats of the form “D.S. al Fine”. I would suggest “\repeat ds” (and “\repeat dc”, unless you want to add magic that recognizes the start of a piece) as the syntax. There is already

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-18 Thread Joel C. Salomon
On 2017-09-17 2:50 AM, David Kastrup wrote: > Carl Sorensen writes: >> On 9/16/17 8:09 AM, "Shamus Hammons" wrote: >> >>> I have a dream, that one day Lilypond will make codas first class >>> citizens instead of having to exist as a series of ugly hacks. In that >>> day, I could simply write \cod

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-17 Thread Kieren MacMillan
Hi Robert (et al.), > I think codas are formatted like this in most professional music scores. Lilypond should continue in its tradition of (a) doing things very well, and (b) wherever/whenever possible, doing things with incredible flexibility and extensibility. Therefore, something along the

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-17 Thread Robert Murdoch
I think codas are formatted like this in most professional music scores. This example was made in MuseScore. ___ lilypond-user mailing list lilypond-user@gnu.org https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-16 Thread David Kastrup
Carl Sorensen writes: > On 9/16/17 8:09 AM, "Shamus Hammons" wrote: > >>I have a dream, that one day Lilypond will make codas first class >>citizens instead of having to exist as a series of ugly hacks. In that >>day, I could simply write \coda (with maybe some options) and Lilypond >>would auto

Re: Problem with Codas

2017-09-16 Thread Carl Sorensen
On 9/16/17 8:09 AM, "Shamus Hammons" wrote: >I have a dream, that one day Lilypond will make codas first class >citizens instead of having to exist as a series of ugly hacks. In that >day, I could simply write \coda (with maybe some options) and Lilypond >would automagically do the right thing. A

Problem with Codas

2017-09-16 Thread Shamus Hammons
http://shamusworld.gotdns.org/music/one-small-child.pdf (see page 2, bars 33-34) I have a dream, that one day Lilypond will make codas first class citizens instead of having to exist as a series of ugly hacks. In that day, I could simply write \coda (with maybe some options) and Lilypond would aut