Re: Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread Thomas Kern
When we had linux on Z, we ran the ntpdate program once per day (before start of business). On our current ESX and Oracle Virtualization (xen), we need to run it every hour. /Tom Kern On 6/4/2012 12:31, David Boyes wrote: > Running NTP everywhere wakes every guest up periodically, so you waste a

Re: Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread r.stricklin
On Jun 4, 2012, at 11:23 AM, Dean, David (I/S) wrote: > Amen. We run it on 60 plus servers, started because of a tie in to Active > Directory on about 4 servers, but continued it on all servers solely to work > and play well with others. I had this requirement and found it sufficient to run

Re: Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread Dean, David (I/S)
Excluding Marcy, of course. -Original Message- From: Dean, David (I/S) Sent: Monday, June 04, 2012 2:23 PM To: 'Linux on 390 Port' Subject: RE: Run NTP on zLinux or not? Amen. We run it on 60 plus servers, started because of a tie in to Active Directory on about 4 servers, but continue

Re: Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread Dean, David (I/S)
Amen. We run it on 60 plus servers, started because of a tie in to Active Directory on about 4 servers, but continued it on all servers solely to work and play well with others. I am 54 years old and come from a complete Window's background 1980-2003, not becoming a "convert" (partial) until 2

Re: Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread David Boyes
> Not running it is also one more > way to make your z type of Linux "different" from the x type of Linux. We > really don't need any more of those. > Marcy Yeah. What she said. -- For LINUX-390 subscribe / signoff / archive a

Re: Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread Marcy Cortes
We run it. It is required by our Kerberos based authentication system and it is required by our security rules. It doesn't seem to take a lot of resources. Not running it is also one more way to make your z type of Linux "different" from the x type of Linux. We really don't need any more of

Re: Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread David Boyes
> > The things that really care about time (like any service using Kerberos > security, or other things that use time as a salt in some other process) need > NTP because they don't work without completely accurate time. > > Everything else can get along fine with running ntpdate once a day. > > II

Re: Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread Rob van der Heij
On Mon, Jun 4, 2012 at 6:31 PM, David Boyes wrote: > The things that really care about time (like any service using Kerberos > security, or other things that use time as a salt in some other process) need > NTP because they don't work without completely accurate time. > Everything else can get

Re: Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread Rob van der Heij
On Mon, Jun 4, 2012 at 6:08 PM, Scott Rohling wrote: > Was having a conversation today about running Linux on System z and whether > it needed to run an NTP client -- the statement being STP is used to keep > the mainframe time in synch, so why run NTP on a Linux guest - the system > time is corr

Re: Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread David Boyes
Running NTP everywhere wakes every guest up periodically, so you waste a fair amount of cycles waking up to do nothing for most guests. The clocks in Linux guests do drift slightly (even if the HW is synced to STP) -- it's order of tenths of microseconds, but it does lose a little (barely meas

Re: Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread McKown, John
I have a vague memory that Linux on z does not use the "timer tick" that some other platforms use. That it uses the z's hardware clock for timing. I think it was the "tickless kernel"? But I don't have a Linux on z system here anymore. Even without STP, the hardware clock is very accurate. I don

Re: Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread Richard Troth
Recommendation leans toward "no", but is not firm. Back before we had STP, I used to say "no", then changed my story to "yes, run it". Lately not so sure. 6 or 7 or more years ago, the point was ... dozens or hundreds of Linux guests ... do you want them all running NTP? At first, "we" said no

Run NTP on zLinux or not?

2012-06-04 Thread Scott Rohling
Was having a conversation today about running Linux on System z and whether it needed to run an NTP client -- the statement being STP is used to keep the mainframe time in synch, so why run NTP on a Linux guest - the system time is correct. My understanding is that Linux maintains it's own clock s