Re: copies= option

2014-05-06 Thread Duncan
Hugo Mills posted on Sun, 04 May 2014 19:31:55 +0100 as excerpted: My proposal was simply a description mechanism, not an implementation. The description is N-copies, M-device-stripe, P-parity-devices (NcMsPp), and (more or less comfortably) covers at minimum all of the current and

Re: copies= option

2014-05-06 Thread Chris Murphy
N-copies, M-device-stripe, P-parity-devices (NcMsPp) At expense of being the terminology nut, who doesn't even like SNIA's chosen terminology because it's confusing, I suggest a concerted effort to either use SNIA's terms anyway, or push back and ask them to make changes before propagating

Re: copies= option

2014-05-04 Thread Brendan Hide
On 2014/05/04 05:27 AM, Duncan wrote: Russell Coker posted on Sun, 04 May 2014 12:16:54 +1000 as excerpted: Are there any plans for a feature like the ZFS copies= option? I'd like to be able to set copies= separately for data and metadata. In most cases RAID-1 provides adequate data

Re: copies= option

2014-05-04 Thread Hugo Mills
like the ZFS copies= option? I'd like to be able to set copies= separately for data and metadata. In most cases RAID-1 provides adequate data protection but I'd like to have RAID-1 and copies=2 for metadata so that if one disk dies and another has some bad sectors during recovery I'm

Re: copies= option

2014-05-04 Thread Duncan
On Sun, 04 May 2014 09:27:10 +0200 Brendan Hide bren...@swiftspirit.co.za wrote: On 2014/05/04 05:27 AM, Duncan wrote: Russell Coker posted on Sun, 04 May 2014 12:16:54 +1000 as excerpted: Are there any plans for a feature like the ZFS copies= option? I'd like to be able to set

copies= option

2014-05-03 Thread Russell Coker
Are there any plans for a feature like the ZFS copies= option? I'd like to be able to set copies= separately for data and metadata. In most cases RAID-1 provides adequate data protection but I'd like to have RAID-1 and copies=2 for metadata so that if one disk dies and another has some bad

Re: copies= option

2014-05-03 Thread Duncan
Russell Coker posted on Sun, 04 May 2014 12:16:54 +1000 as excerpted: Are there any plans for a feature like the ZFS copies= option? I'd like to be able to set copies= separately for data and metadata. In most cases RAID-1 provides adequate data protection but I'd like to have RAID-1