Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-29 Thread John Golubenko
Alan Cox wrote: > > > Features I would like in the kernel: > > 1: Make the whole insmod-rmmod tingie a kernel internal so they could be > > trigged before rootmount. > > Already there. In fact Red Hat uses it for the scsi devices. That is what > initrd is for. > > > 2: Compile time

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-29 Thread John Golubenko
Alan Cox wrote: Features I would like in the kernel: 1: Make the whole insmod-rmmod tingie a kernel internal so they could be trigged before rootmount. Already there. In fact Red Hat uses it for the scsi devices. That is what initrd is for. 2: Compile time optimization options in

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-27 Thread Julien Laganier
John Nilsson wrote: > > Well I thought that it was time for me to give some feedback to the linux > community. So I will tell you guys a little of my experience with linux so > far. > > I have a Toshiba Portégé 3010CT laptop. That is: > 266MHz Pentium-MMX > 4GB HD with 512kb cache (which linux

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-27 Thread Julien Laganier
John Nilsson wrote: Well I thought that it was time for me to give some feedback to the linux community. So I will tell you guys a little of my experience with linux so far. I have a Toshiba Portégé 3010CT laptop. That is: 266MHz Pentium-MMX 4GB HD with 512kb cache (which linux reduces

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread Joseph Pingenot
>From Android on Sunday, 24 June, 2001: >>I have come to the conclusion that linux is NOT suitable for the general >>desktop market. >I have to disagree on this. It runs fine on most PC's, as they use standard >devices. Just say NO to anything proprietary. This includes Toshiba. Makers of such

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread John Nilsson
> > 8: A way to change kernel without rebooting. I have no diskdrive or >cddrive > > in my laptop so I often do drastic things when I install a new >distribution. > >Well, don't do drastic things then, if that cause problems! =) First of all that part was intended as a joke ;) but what I meant

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread PALFFY Daniel
On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, John Nilsson wrote: > I have a Toshiba Portégé 3010CT laptop. That is: > 266MHz Pentium-MMX > 4GB HD with 512kb cache (which linux reduces to 0kb) > 32 Mb EDO RAM I have the same machine with 64 MB ram, and it's quite well supported with linux. I do most of my daily work on

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread Luigi Genoni
On Mon, 25 Jun 2001, Dieter Nützel wrote: > > > > 8: A way to change kernel without rebooting. I have no diskdrive or > > > cddrive in my laptop so I often do drastic things when I install a new > > > distribution. > > > > Thats actually an incredibly hard problem to solve. The only people who

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread Helge Hafting
John Nilsson wrote: [everything else answered by others] > 8: A way to change kernel without rebooting. I have no diskdrive or cddrive > in my laptop so I often do drastic things when I install a new distribution. Well, don't do drastic things then, if that cause problems! My machines have

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread Eric W. Biederman
David Lang <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > if you don't preserve things running in userspace what advantage do you > have over rebooting? I use it as part of a bootloader. Allowing me to boot one kernel directly from another. I guess it really is a soft reboot that never touches any BIOS. I

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread David Lang
that the kernel structures may change on you. David Lang On 24 Jun 2001 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > Date: 24 Jun 2001 21:48:20 -0600 > From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > To: David Lang <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Cc: John Nilsson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Subject: Re: Some expe

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread David Lang
that the kernel structures may change on you. David Lang On 24 Jun 2001 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Date: 24 Jun 2001 21:48:20 -0600 From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: David Lang [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: John Nilsson [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop David Lang

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread Eric W. Biederman
David Lang [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: if you don't preserve things running in userspace what advantage do you have over rebooting? I use it as part of a bootloader. Allowing me to boot one kernel directly from another. I guess it really is a soft reboot that never touches any BIOS. I don't

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread Helge Hafting
John Nilsson wrote: [everything else answered by others] 8: A way to change kernel without rebooting. I have no diskdrive or cddrive in my laptop so I often do drastic things when I install a new distribution. Well, don't do drastic things then, if that cause problems! My machines have both

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread Luigi Genoni
On Mon, 25 Jun 2001, Dieter Nützel wrote: 8: A way to change kernel without rebooting. I have no diskdrive or cddrive in my laptop so I often do drastic things when I install a new distribution. Thats actually an incredibly hard problem to solve. The only people who do this

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread PALFFY Daniel
On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, John Nilsson wrote: I have a Toshiba Portégé 3010CT laptop. That is: 266MHz Pentium-MMX 4GB HD with 512kb cache (which linux reduces to 0kb) 32 Mb EDO RAM I have the same machine with 64 MB ram, and it's quite well supported with linux. I do most of my daily work on it

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread John Nilsson
8: A way to change kernel without rebooting. I have no diskdrive or cddrive in my laptop so I often do drastic things when I install a new distribution. Well, don't do drastic things then, if that cause problems! =) First of all that part was intended as a joke ;) but what I meant is

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-25 Thread Joseph Pingenot
From Android on Sunday, 24 June, 2001: I have come to the conclusion that linux is NOT suitable for the general desktop market. I have to disagree on this. It runs fine on most PC's, as they use standard devices. Just say NO to anything proprietary. This includes Toshiba. Makers of such odd

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Eric W. Biederman
David Lang <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, John Nilsson wrote: > > 8: A way to change kernel without rebooting. I have no diskdrive or cddrive > > in my laptop so I often do drastic things when I install a new distribution. > > this is suggested every few months, the normal

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Eric W. Biederman
Alan Cox <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > > 8: A way to change kernel without rebooting. I have no diskdrive or cddrive > > in my laptop so I often do drastic things when I install a new distribution. > > Thats actually an incredibly hard problem to solve. The only people who do > this level of

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Dieter Nützel
Alan wrote: > > > 4: make bzImage && make modules && make modules install && cp > > arch/i386/boot/bzImage /boot/'uname -r' something inside make menuconfig > > So really you want an outside GUI tool that lets you reconfigure build and > install kernels. Yeah I'd agree with that. Someone just

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Luigi Genoni
John Nilson wrote: > 2: Compile time optimization options in Make menuconfig I do not understand the point. > 3: Lilo/grub config in make menuconfig Unusefull and dangerous. > 4: make bzImage && make modules && make modules install && cp > arch/i386/boot/bzImage /boot/'uname -r'

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Hua Zhong
> So really you want an outside GUI tool that lets you reconfigure build and > install kernels. Yeah I'd agree with that. Someone just needs to write the > killer gnome/kde config tool. I've got C code for parsing/loading config.in > files and deducing the dependancy constraints if anyone ever

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Jeff Chua
On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, John Nilsson wrote: > I have a Toshiba Portégé 3010CT laptop. That is: > 266MHz Pentium-MMX > 4GB HD with 512kb cache (which linux reduces to 0kb) > 32 Mb EDO RAM tons of info out there. http://www.tce.co.jp/linux/ http://www.buzzard.org.uk/toshiba/

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Daniel Phillips
On Monday 25 June 2001 00:12, Alan Cox wrote: > > > So when you speak of being able to run on 386:es I still have problem > > > starting X on 266MHz with 32Mb mem. This should not be =) > > > > That's true. Usually, X by itself starts pretty fast. Just try 'xinit', > > no parameters. KDE and

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Alan Cox
> then to either a test linux or stable linux environment from the C drive. > I setup a Menu in config.sys under dos to select which linux to boot up. > If the test kernel doesn't work, I reboot the system to switch to the > stable one. At least better than carrying a floppy around. That is

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread William Stearns
Good day, John, Alan, On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, Alan Cox wrote: > > 4: make bzImage && make modules && make modules install && cp > > arch/i386/boot/bzImage /boot/'uname -r' something inside make menuconfig > > So really you want an outside GUI tool that lets you reconfigure build and > install

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Alan Cox
> > So when you speak of being able to run on 386:es I still have problem > > starting X on 266MHz with 32Mb mem. This should not be =) > > That's true. Usually, X by itself starts pretty fast. Just try 'xinit', no > parameters. KDE and Gnome both need to go on a diet, especially KDE. They

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Jeff Chua
On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, Alan Cox wrote: > > 8: A way to change kernel without rebooting. I have no diskdrive or cddrive > > in my laptop so I often do drastic things when I install a new distribution. > > Thats actually an incredibly hard problem to solve. The only people who do > this level of

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Rik van Riel
On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, John Nilsson wrote: > Well I thought that it was time for me to give some feedback to > the linux community. So I will tell you guys a little of my > experience with linux so far. Two words: "send patches" Please put your money where your mouth is. I mean, it's ok if you

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Daniel Phillips
On Sunday 24 June 2001 22:51, John Nilsson wrote: > So a little plea is that you let the optimization phase cooldown a > little and concern your self a little more with compatibility, and ease of > installation, (tidy up the kernel build system). /me has no intention of cooling down the

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Alan Cox
> Features I would like in the kernel: > 1: Make the whole insmod-rmmod tingie a kernel internal so they could be > trigged before rootmount. Already there. In fact Red Hat uses it for the scsi devices. That is what initrd is for. > 2: Compile time optimization options in Make menuconfig

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread David Lang
On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, John Nilsson wrote: > Date: Sun, 24 Jun 2001 22:51:56 +0200 > From: John Nilsson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Subject: Some experience of linux on a Laptop > > Well I thought that it was time for me to give some feedback to the

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Andrzej Krzysztofowicz
> >Features I would like in the kernel: > >1: Make the whole insmod-rmmod tingie a kernel internal so they could be > >trigged before rootmount. > > How can you load modules into the kernel before root is mounted? > No harddrive accessible means no modules. initrd ? It's quite popular feature

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Android
>I have come to the conclusion that linux is NOT suitable for the general >desktop market. I have to disagree on this. It runs fine on most PC's, as they use standard devices. Just say NO to anything proprietary. This includes Toshiba. Makers of such odd machines should supply their own

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Fabian Arias
Well, let's see: On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, John Nilsson wrote: > Well I thought that it was time for me to give some feedback to the linux > community. So I will tell you guys a little of my experience with linux so > far. > > I have a Toshiba Portégé 3010CT laptop. That is: > 266MHz Pentium-MMX

Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread John Nilsson
Well I thought that it was time for me to give some feedback to the linux community. So I will tell you guys a little of my experience with linux so far. I have a Toshiba Portégé 3010CT laptop. That is: 266MHz Pentium-MMX 4GB HD with 512kb cache (which linux reduces to 0kb) 32 Mb EDO RAM

Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread John Nilsson
Well I thought that it was time for me to give some feedback to the linux community. So I will tell you guys a little of my experience with linux so far. I have a Toshiba Portégé 3010CT laptop. That is: 266MHz Pentium-MMX 4GB HD with 512kb cache (which linux reduces to 0kb) 32 Mb EDO RAM

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Fabian Arias
Well, let's see: On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, John Nilsson wrote: Well I thought that it was time for me to give some feedback to the linux community. So I will tell you guys a little of my experience with linux so far. I have a Toshiba Portégé 3010CT laptop. That is: 266MHz Pentium-MMX 4GB

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Android
I have come to the conclusion that linux is NOT suitable for the general desktop market. I have to disagree on this. It runs fine on most PC's, as they use standard devices. Just say NO to anything proprietary. This includes Toshiba. Makers of such odd machines should supply their own native

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Andrzej Krzysztofowicz
Features I would like in the kernel: 1: Make the whole insmod-rmmod tingie a kernel internal so they could be trigged before rootmount. How can you load modules into the kernel before root is mounted? No harddrive accessible means no modules. initrd ? It's quite popular feature at

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread David Lang
On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, John Nilsson wrote: Date: Sun, 24 Jun 2001 22:51:56 +0200 From: John Nilsson [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Some experience of linux on a Laptop Well I thought that it was time for me to give some feedback to the linux community. So I will tell you

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Daniel Phillips
On Sunday 24 June 2001 22:51, John Nilsson wrote: So a little plea is that you let the optimization phase cooldown a little and concern your self a little more with compatibility, and ease of installation, (tidy up the kernel build system). /me has no intention of cooling down the

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Rik van Riel
On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, John Nilsson wrote: Well I thought that it was time for me to give some feedback to the linux community. So I will tell you guys a little of my experience with linux so far. Two words: send patches Please put your money where your mouth is. I mean, it's ok if you send

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Jeff Chua
On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, John Nilsson wrote: I have a Toshiba Portégé 3010CT laptop. That is: 266MHz Pentium-MMX 4GB HD with 512kb cache (which linux reduces to 0kb) 32 Mb EDO RAM tons of info out there. http://www.tce.co.jp/linux/ http://www.buzzard.org.uk/toshiba/

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Luigi Genoni
John Nilson wrote: 2: Compile time optimization options in Make menuconfig I do not understand the point. 3: Lilo/grub config in make menuconfig Unusefull and dangerous. 4: make bzImage make modules make modules install cp arch/i386/boot/bzImage /boot/'uname -r' something inside

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Dieter Nützel
Alan wrote: 4: make bzImage make modules make modules install cp arch/i386/boot/bzImage /boot/'uname -r' something inside make menuconfig So really you want an outside GUI tool that lets you reconfigure build and install kernels. Yeah I'd agree with that. Someone just needs to write

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Eric W. Biederman
David Lang [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, John Nilsson wrote: 8: A way to change kernel without rebooting. I have no diskdrive or cddrive in my laptop so I often do drastic things when I install a new distribution. this is suggested every few months, the normal answer is

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread William Stearns
Good day, John, Alan, On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, Alan Cox wrote: 4: make bzImage make modules make modules install cp arch/i386/boot/bzImage /boot/'uname -r' something inside make menuconfig So really you want an outside GUI tool that lets you reconfigure build and install kernels. Yeah I'd

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Alan Cox
So when you speak of being able to run on 386:es I still have problem starting X on 266MHz with 32Mb mem. This should not be =) That's true. Usually, X by itself starts pretty fast. Just try 'xinit', no parameters. KDE and Gnome both need to go on a diet, especially KDE. They The

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Alan Cox
then to either a test linux or stable linux environment from the C drive. I setup a Menu in config.sys under dos to select which linux to boot up. If the test kernel doesn't work, I reboot the system to switch to the stable one. At least better than carrying a floppy around. That is

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Daniel Phillips
On Monday 25 June 2001 00:12, Alan Cox wrote: So when you speak of being able to run on 386:es I still have problem starting X on 266MHz with 32Mb mem. This should not be =) That's true. Usually, X by itself starts pretty fast. Just try 'xinit', no parameters. KDE and Gnome both

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Hua Zhong
So really you want an outside GUI tool that lets you reconfigure build and install kernels. Yeah I'd agree with that. Someone just needs to write the killer gnome/kde config tool. I've got C code for parsing/loading config.in files and deducing the dependancy constraints if anyone ever wants

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Alan Cox
Features I would like in the kernel: 1: Make the whole insmod-rmmod tingie a kernel internal so they could be trigged before rootmount. Already there. In fact Red Hat uses it for the scsi devices. That is what initrd is for. 2: Compile time optimization options in Make menuconfig such as

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Jeff Chua
On Sun, 24 Jun 2001, Alan Cox wrote: 8: A way to change kernel without rebooting. I have no diskdrive or cddrive in my laptop so I often do drastic things when I install a new distribution. Thats actually an incredibly hard problem to solve. The only people who do this level of stuff are

Re: Some experience of linux on a Laptop

2001-06-24 Thread Eric W. Biederman
Alan Cox [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: 8: A way to change kernel without rebooting. I have no diskdrive or cddrive in my laptop so I often do drastic things when I install a new distribution. Thats actually an incredibly hard problem to solve. The only people who do this level of stuff are