Re: the 12 disk limit

1999-09-02 Thread Lawrence Dickson
All, The simple patch suggested by Lance Robinson was successful in bringing up 18 disk RAID-5 on our stock RedHat 6.0 system. The changes were made on a "pure" kernel,modules,raidtools with no other previous customization. Our test was on partitions distributed over 2 disks. We got repeat

RE: the 12 disk limit

1999-08-31 Thread Lawrence Dickson
All, MANY THANKS for this TREMENDOUS response to my query - at least 3 paths to a solution, wow! We'll try Lance's patch to start with, and let you know how it works. (We're still with stock RH 6.0.) But an official 27 disk solution will be really nice once we figure out how to upgrade the res

[oops] the limit is 27 disks! (Re: the 12 disk limit)

1999-08-31 Thread Ingo Molnar
On Mon, 30 Aug 1999, D. Lance Robinson wrote: > #define MD_SB_DESCRIPTOR_WORDS 32 > #define MD_SB_DISKS 20 > #define MD_SB_DISK_WORDS (MD_SB_DESCRIPTOR_WORDS * MD_SB_DISKS) oops. I've just re-checked the superblock layout calculations to prove you wrong, but actually it t

Re: the 12 disk limit

1999-08-31 Thread Jason Lavoie
On 08/30, D. Lance Robinson wrote: > Lawrence, > > If you don't care about being 'standard', There is plenty of fluff in > the superblock to make room for more disks. I don't know how well > behaved all the tools are at using the symbolic constants though. [...] > Try it out, let us know if the

Re: the 12 disk limit

1999-08-30 Thread Mr. James W. Laferriere
Hello Ingo , Yes, Yes, yes Thank you Ingo . more below . On Tue, 31 Aug 1999, Ingo Molnar wrote: > On Mon, 30 Aug 1999, Lawrence Dickson wrote: > > >I guess this has been asked before, but - when will the RAID code get > > past the 12 disk limit? We'd even be willing to us

Re: the 12 disk limit

1999-08-30 Thread Ingo Molnar
On Mon, 30 Aug 1999, Lawrence Dickson wrote: >I guess this has been asked before, but - when will the RAID code get > past the 12 disk limit? We'd even be willing to use a variant - our > customer wants 18 disk RAID-5 real bad. yes, this has been requested before. I'm now mainly working on

Re: the 12 disk limit

1999-08-30 Thread D. Lance Robinson
Lawrence, If you don't care about being 'standard', There is plenty of fluff in the superblock to make room for more disks. I don't know how well behaved all the tools are at using the symbolic constants though. To Support 18 devices, you will need to allow at least 19 disks (one for the spare/r

RE: the 12 disk limit

1999-08-30 Thread Tom Livingston
Lawrence Dickson wrote: >I guess this has been asked before, but - when will the RAID > code get past the 12 disk limit? We'd even be willing to use > a variant - our customer wants 18 disk RAID-5 real bad. A solution you may already be aware of is to use two 9 disk RAID5 sets, and then use t